Blog
Eastenders explores rape: Part 5 - what happens when a complainant wants to "drop the case"?
Maeve Keenan
A simple caution is a non-statutory, non-conviction disposal for adult offenders aged 18 or over. Simple cautions are normally issued by the police at a police station. A simple caution is not the same as a conviction but can have significant consequences (see below).
Simple cautions are intended for low-level, first-time offending. Thus, simple cautions are not ordinarily given for serious crimes that would be tried in the Crown Court or for certain offences that could be tried either in the Magistrates Court or the Crown Court.
A simple caution can only be offered to someone who has admitted that he or she is guilty of the relevant offence. A simple caution should not ordinarily be offered to an offender who has raised a defence (e.g. self-defence) or who does not agree to accept the caution. Finally, a simple caution should only be given if the police are satisfied that there is a realistic prospect of conviction, were that person to be prosecuted.
Generally speaking, a simple caution should not be given where the person has been cautioned for or convicted of the same or similar offences within two years of the commission of current offence unless there are exceptional circumstances.
A person must understand the implications of acceptance, including that the simple caution:
a) will be recorded on that person’s criminal record;
b) may potentially be disclosed on a DBS certificate;
c) may potentially be disclosed to employers and regulatory bodies;
d) the person will be placed on the "sex offenders register" in the case of prescribed sex offences;
e) may be used in family law related proceedings;
f) may not preclude the institution of a private prosecution;
g) may be used in related civil claims; and
h) may have consequences for travel and immigration purposes.
No. An individual retains the right to decline the offer of a simple caution and face being prosecuted instead.
There is no right of appeal once a simple caution has given and accepted. However, the administration of a simple caution may be challenged by a complaint to the police and an application for expungement. Ultimately, a person may also seek to have the simple caution quashed by a High Court claim for judicial review.
A person may make a complaint to the relevant police force and, where certain grounds are satisfied (such as the person having raised a defence to the offence before the administration of the simple caution) the police may expunge the caution. Following this, it will be removed from the person’s criminal record, but it may a still be relevant for immigration purposes.
a) PNC record - until the person is deemed to have reached 100 years of age, unless there are exceptional circumstances.
b) PND record - this depends on local police force’s own policies and other forms of guidance.
c) DBS certificate - in general terms, so long as the simple caution remains on the PNC it will remain on any DBS certificate, except those which, under the filtering rules, should no longer be disclosed (see below).
In certain situations, ‘old’ cautions will not appear on a DBS certificate. The DBS service will ‘filter’ the individual’s record. The filtering rules provide that an adult simple caution will be removed after 6 years have elapsed since the date of the caution – and if it does not appear on the list of offences relevant to safeguarding.
If you have any questions relating to simple cautions, please contact a member of our criminal litigation team.
The KN team are one of the best known, oldest and highly regarded teams in this area of work. They get first rate work and deliver excellent results."
Legal 500 UK 2021
The lawyers on the crime team are relentlessly good at what they do. They have a collaborative approach and are incredibly thorough and detailed in their work."
Chambers UK 2021
Highly collaborative and team based in everything they do. Friendly and down to earth while also being world class. Uniquely able to bring together the brightest and the best but without being pompous or superior in their attitude. Great listeners, hard workers and tactically the best in the business."
Legal 500 UK 2021
In dealing with the firm, every aspect was outstanding and of the highest quality."
Chambers UK 2021
KN are exceptional in almost all categories! They are streaks ahead of everyone else and provide a very high level of service. If I were in trouble that’s where I would go. I like the fact they are genuinely committed to providing excellence even on less lucrative cases or on cases of less seriousness. They completely get how serious every case is for a client . They unfailing do the very best for their clients."
Legal 500 UK 2021
A dynamic team that shows good attention to detail."
Chambers UK 2021
The general crime department is the best I have ever worked with. They are unsurpassed in the way they work as a team on their cases - it's a very well-drilled, slick operation."
Chambers UK 2020 - A Client’s Guide to the UK Legal Profession
Kingsley Napley has real strength and expertise at all levels of the crime group. The team is hard-working, focused on getting results and yet maintains the human touch."
Legal 500 UK 2020
They are able to draw on expertise across the firm to provide a seamless service - if you are facing criminal allegations they can also handle the media, as well as any employment issues or regulatory proceedings that may arise."
Chambers UK 2020 - A Client’s Guide to the UK Legal Profession
Maeve Keenan
Maeve Keenan
Skip to content Home About Us Insights Services Contact Accessibility