Our Clinical Negligence team secured a six figure settlement for a teenager who had suffered serious sexual abuse.
The Case: Our client was a teenager over the age of consent who had become involved in sexual activity with a middle-aged partner. While it originally seemed that s/he had agreed to the relationship, it soon became clear that s/he had been groomed by the older party.
Their consent was in truth, submission.
While it is often thought not possible to pursue a criminal or civil case against a sexual abuser if the victim has the capacity to, or gives the appearance of, consent, this case shows that all circumstances must be examined.
Some of the issues a Court may consider include:
- the claimant's age and the age gap between the claimant and the abuser;
- the claimant’s intelligence and maturity;
- any background grooming;
- the claimant's prior level of sexual experience;
- the status and power of the abuser;
- whether the claimant appeared to be a willing/active participant or a passive participant;
- the vulnerability of the claimant;
- dishonesty of the defendant;
- whether the defendant held a position of influence over the claimant;
- whether there is a distortion of the legitimate relationship between the parties;
- the provision of alcohol and drugs and the effect on the complainant;
- the use and/or threat of violence and intimidation;
- the use of other means of control such as emotional or situation control; and
- If the sexual activity constituted a criminal offence, it may be worth considering the underling rationale for making such behaviour an offence (NB as a criminal offence will not in of itself establish an actionable tort).
Our team, led by Terry Donovan and Aideen McGarry, gathered supporting evidence against the accused which included the police file and court documents relating to the complaint, the relevant medical records and comprehensive witness statements from the victim and their family.
We also asked an expert psychiatrist and psychologist to prepare reports outlining the detrimental effects of the relationship between the victim and the older party.
The outcome:
In order to calculate the appropriate compensation, we provided an accurate value of the sum needed by the victim to receive the necessary psychological treatment and get their education and career back on track.
The final amount was negotiated between the parties at a joint settlement meeting, so avoiding the need for court proceedings.
If you have any questions or concerns about the topics raised in this case study please contact a member of the Medical Negligence and Personal Injury team at claims@kingsleynapley.co.uk or call us on 020 7814 1200.
Latest blogs and news
HSSIB contributes to the national investigation into maternity and neonatal services – but will change ever be implemented?
The Health Services Safety Investigations Body (HSSIB) has shared insights into safety concerns raised by women and families and other stakeholders about maternity and neonatal care within NHS England, highlighting once again the need for meaningful change.
NHS Patient Safety Investigations: Have I got a Legal Claim?
Where there has been a concern surrounding medical care at an NHS Hospital, an internal investigation may be carried out and a written report produced to assist with learning from the incident. From a patient perspective, the report can be helpful in understanding more about the event and what, if anything, went wrong.
Problems with glaucoma care at the George Eliot Hospital NHS Trust
We are extremely concerned to read reports that treatment guidelines relating to glaucoma allegedly have not been followed at the George Eliot Hospital NHS Trust in Warwickshire, leading to patients’ sight being harmed. Some patients are said to have suffered permanent visual damage.
NHSR Annual Report: Clinical Negligence under the spotlight
Each year NHS Resolution, the body dealing with legal claims against the NHS, produces a report which provides insights into what is happening with clinical negligence claims. This year the picture is very mixed. It shows that claims for clinical negligence are on the rise although more cases are being settled without the need for Court proceedings. Nonetheless, despite Government efforts, high levels of maternity cases and associated costs persist.
Providing Medical Treatment to a Non-English-Speaking Patient
In this blog, Richard Lodge talks about providing medical treatment to a non-english speaking patient
Outdated, Failing and in Short Supply: NHS Equipment Crisis Putting Patients at Risk
According to a recent article in The Guardian NHS England has confirmed that since 2022, equipment failures within the NHS have been responsible for:
- 87 patient deaths
- 68 patients severely harmed who suffered permanent damage or reduced life expectancy
- 522 patients moderately harmed whose independence was subsequently limited for up to 6 months
James Bell published in the APIL PI Focus Magazine
Kingsley Napley’s head of Medical Negligence and Personal Injury has had an article published in this month’s APIL PI Focus magazine which includes a collection of articles examining the topic of birth injury. James’ piece deals with causation and the doctrine of material contribution in legal claims for hypoxic brain injuries during birth.
When metal hip replacements go wrong
Hip replacement surgery is very common, restoring mobility and quality of life to thousands every year in the UK. It is recognised to be the most cost effective for the NHS in returning patients to productive lives. The components wearing surfaces may be metal, ceramic or plastic, and will often last over 20 to 25 years, or even longer for some people.
Is this the turning point for maternity care?
Concerns over NHS maternity care are very sadly seldom out of the news. As a lawyer who has specialised in birth injury claims over many years, it has been all too clear to me for a long time, that far too many women and babies, fail to receive anywhere close to adequate maternity care leading in some instances to devastating outcomes.
Why Fatigue of NHS Staff Matters and the Risk it Poses to Patient Safety
Fatigue within the NHS presents a significant risk to patient safety, yet in healthcare its consequences remain largely unrecognised despite the increasing demands on NHS workforces.
Litigation Friends
While we mostly associate dementia with the affect it can have on our memory, it can also affect our ability to think and communicate and our capacity to manage our own affairs. When undertaking legal proceedings, as solicitors, we have a duty to ensure that our clients have the mental capacity to give proper instructions to bring, or defend, a claim. Where our client does not have the necessary capacity, a Litigation Friend may be appointed
Brain injuries: the good, the bad and the inspiring
We are now in Action for Brain Injury week, run annually by the charity Headway to raise awareness and understanding of the different aspects of brain injury. The theme this year is ‘On a good day’ which aims to highlight the fluctuating and unpredictable nature of brain injury and the gap that can arise between someone’s capabilities on a good day versus a bad day. Headway wants people to see both sides of the story. It seeks to change behaviours and opinions towards those who might be having an ‘all-too-common bad day’.
Women’s Health Series 4: Cancer Claims
New research suggests that UK cancer cases have risen in women but fallen in men. Women’s cancers include gynaecological cancer (i.e. cervical, ovarian and vaginal cancers) and breast cancer. Here I look at the impacts of delays in diagnosis and treatment failures, provide some guidance on bringing a medical negligence claim and consider why there is hope for the future with new technologies.
Women’s Health Series: 3. Hysterectomy Claims
A lack of awareness and understanding appears to exist when it comes to women’s reproductive health conditions, and the diagnosis and treatment of hysterectomies is no exception to this.
In this blog we will be discussing where negligence can occur in relation to the treatment of hysterectomies, from initial misdiagnoses to surgical errors.
Women’s Health Series: 2. Endometriosis, Pelvic Inflammatory Disease and Fertility Claims
Endometriosis and Pelvic Inflammatory Disease (PID) are two conditions which affect a large number of women every year, and can have devastating effects on fertility and well-being, but frustratingly continue to experience long delays in diagnosis.
Women’s Health Series: 1. Gynaecology Care Crisis
As a lawyer specialising in women’s health claims, I am increasingly concerned about the challenges facing those seeking access to care for issues around gynaecology and reproductive health. Problems in this area are rife. They include very long waiting times, delays in diagnosis, a lack of understanding by some medical professionals, instances of discrimination as well as women reporting feelings of being dismissed.
Missed screening for life threatening conditions
We are extremely concerned that it has been revealed thousands of patients have not been invited for routine screening for certain cancers and for abdominal aortic aneurism as a result of failings in their GP registration process. The full impact of this is not yet known but records indicate that among those not screened, some people have been diagnosed with a relevant cancer and some may have died.
Hypoxic Ischaemic Encephalopathy and Brain Damage Claims
Our Medical Negligence team at Kingsley Napley has recently been supporting pioneering charity Peeps HIE as a Corporate Friend. Globally, hypoxic-ischaemic encephalopathy (HIE) is a leading cause of disability, affecting around three million babies each year. This fantastic charity – the only one in the UK dedicated to supporting those affected by HIE – provides essential help to parents, families and friends.
Gestational Diabetes – The Case for Early Diagnosis
Gestational diabetes affects 1 in 20 pregnancies in the UK, according to Diabetes UK. The condition involves high blood sugar levels, resulting from the body not being able to produce sufficient insulin because of hormone changes, and can occur at any point during pregnancy. Being diagnosed with gestational diabetes can be worrying, but with proper management, most women diagnosed with gestational diabetes will have a healthy baby and a normal pregnancy. However, the condition can pose risks to both mother and baby. Early detection and proper management and support are vital to reduce the risks and new research suggests there would be benefits from changing the way the condition is diagnosed.
Landmark reform: no time limit for Child Sexual Abuse claims
Today the Government announced landmark reform to child sexual abuse personal injury claims. In legislation expected to be put before parliament next year, the 3-year time limit to bring such claims, which begins to run from a Claimant’s 18th birthday, will be abolished. The burden of proof on determining whether there can be a fair hearing will also shift, from the Claimant to the Defendant.
