Blog
Multiple missed opportunities in paediatric orthopaedic care at Addenbrooke's Hospital
James Bell
Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust have published a report dealing with concerns around the practice of a trauma and orthopaedic consultant, Ms Kuldeep Stohr, who specialised in treating children at Addenbrooke's Hospital. A clinical review of around 800 patients is now underway. Ms Stohr has been suspended.
The issues raised are extremely concerning as multiple opportunities were missed to take action that potentially could have prevented harm to children.
The ‘Verita’ report details the findings of an independent investigation into whether there were opportunities to have earlier identified and addressed issues with Ms Stohr’s practice. The investigation did not examine individual patient care. A separate independent clinical review is now being carried out by a panel of expert clinicians, led by Andrew Kennedy KC, which is expected to conclude next year. The panel will examine the treatment of around 800 patients. This follows an initial review of complex hip surgery cases in recent years which found that nine children had received substandard care.
Concerns about Ms Stohr’s practice were raised as far back as 2015. An external clinical review was undertaken in 2016 by paediatric orthopaedic surgeon Mr Robert Hill after a senior colleague had raised concerns about Ms Stohr’s surgical practice. Mr Hill’s report identified shortcomings in Ms Stohr’s surgery, concluded that there was a need for technical improvements and made recommendations. However, the Verita investigation found that the Hill report was not adequately interpreted or communicated. The report states: ‘The two surgeons were led to believe that the principal problem was their poor relationship’. This seems to have distracted from the clinical shortcomings raised. The report does note that Ms Stohr ‘understood the findings of the Hill report and made her own efforts to improve her clinical practice. She did this without the help and support of the Trust.’
The Verita report in fact highlights that there were some 32 missed opportunities to address concerns over Ms Stohr’s practice between 2012 and 2024. The report concludes: ‘If these opportunities had been recognised at the time, appropriate actions could have been taken. Those actions would likely have reduced harm to paediatric orthopaedic patients.’
The Trust have apologised for the missed opportunities identified and the impact that this has had on patients and their families. According to the Trust, Pippa Heylings, MP for South Cambridgeshire, commented: ‘There has been harm done and that harm could have been avoided….. I will be holding the hospital to account on the delivery of the changes needed to ensure that nothing like this can be allowed to happen again.’ She went on to say that ‘the report makes clear that staff and senior consultants have not felt able to raise concerns about risk and harmful practice.’
The Trust say they are implementing an action plan which includes improving governance for the safety and effectiveness of clinical services and improving support for doctors. They also say that they are embedding an open and accountable medical culture. This is clearly key to preventing any similar incident in the future.
Orthopaedic legal claims
Our team at Kinglsey Napley are highly specialist in dealing with medical negligence claims relating to orthopaedic treatment and surgeries. More information is available on the following pages:
If you or a loved one are concerned about orthopaedic treatment, please contact our sensitive team for a no obligation discussion.
Multiple missed opportunities in paediatric orthopaedic care at Addenbrooke's Hospital
Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust have published a report dealing with concerns around the practices of a trauma and orthopaedic consultant, Ms Kuldeep Stohr, who specialised in treating children at Addenbrooke's Hospital. A clinical review of 800 patients is now underway. Ms Stohr has been suspended.
Unique and United on World Cerebral Palsy Day 2025
This year, World Cerebral Palsy Day falls on 6 October with a theme of ‘#Unique and United’. The Kingsley Napley Medical Negligence and Personal Injury team strongly support the vision of this global movement - which is about recognition of the 50 million people who are living with cerebral palsy and striving for a more accessible and inclusive world.
Where Every Minute Counts: Hypoxic Birth Injuries – Causation and Material Contribution
Legal claims for hypoxic brain injuries during birth – caused by a disruption in oxygen supply - remain prevalent. These injuries can have a devastating impact and lead to lifelong conditions including Cerebral Palsy. Indeed, claims relating to brain injuries sustained during birth account for a significant percentage of the total value of clinical negligence damages paid out each year. This is because the average amount of damages for such cases is very high, not infrequently running to tens of millions of pounds, with some impacted children having lifelong needs for care, treatment, equipment and housing. Nonetheless, claims for clinical negligence in this area can be particularly thorny to prove. In this article I consider when the doctrine of ‘material contribution’ – said by the Court of Appeal to have been ‘bedevilled by apparent inconsistency’ – may apply to hypoxic birth injury cases where the window for avoiding injury can be short. Does every minute really count?
14 Maternity Trusts to be Scrutinised as Part of National Investigation
The Government has this week confirmed the names of 14 Hospital Trusts that will be part of a rapid national investigation of maternity and newborn baby care across England that was announced by Wes Streeting back in June. (See my colleague Sharon Burkill’s blog on that announcement here). I am carefully watching the developments with regard to this investigation, knowing full well from my clients and their stories how desperately improvements to our maternity services are needed.
Kingsley Napley’s Medical Negligence Team ‘walks together’ with the Dame Vera Lynn Children’s Charity
We were delighted to take part in a 15km walk on Saturday 6 September for the Dame Vera Lynn Children’s Charity (DVLCC) to raise funds for this excellent cause.
HSSIB contributes to the national investigation into maternity and neonatal services – but will change ever be implemented?
The Health Services Safety Investigations Body (HSSIB) has shared insights into safety concerns raised by women and families and other stakeholders about maternity and neonatal care within NHS England, highlighting once again the need for meaningful change.
NHS Patient Safety Investigations: Have I got a Legal Claim?
Where there has been a concern surrounding medical care at an NHS Hospital, an internal investigation may be carried out and a written report produced to assist with learning from the incident. From a patient perspective, the report can be helpful in understanding more about the event and what, if anything, went wrong.
Problems with glaucoma care at the George Eliot Hospital NHS Trust
We are extremely concerned to read reports that treatment guidelines relating to glaucoma allegedly have not been followed at the George Eliot Hospital NHS Trust in Warwickshire, leading to patients’ sight being harmed. Some patients are said to have suffered permanent visual damage.
NHSR Annual Report: Clinical Negligence under the spotlight
Each year NHS Resolution, the body dealing with legal claims against the NHS, produces a report which provides insights into what is happening with clinical negligence claims. This year the picture is very mixed. It shows that claims for clinical negligence are on the rise although more cases are being settled without the need for Court proceedings. Nonetheless, despite Government efforts, high levels of maternity cases and associated costs persist.
Providing Medical Treatment to a Non-English-Speaking Patient
In this blog, Richard Lodge talks about providing medical treatment to a non-english speaking patient
Outdated, Failing and in Short Supply: NHS Equipment Crisis Putting Patients at Risk
According to a recent article in The Guardian NHS England has confirmed that since 2022, equipment failures within the NHS have been responsible for:
- 87 patient deaths
- 68 patients severely harmed who suffered permanent damage or reduced life expectancy
- 522 patients moderately harmed whose independence was subsequently limited for up to 6 months
James Bell published in the APIL PI Focus Magazine
Kingsley Napley’s head of Medical Negligence and Personal Injury has had an article published in this month’s APIL PI Focus magazine which includes a collection of articles examining the topic of birth injury. James’ piece deals with causation and the doctrine of material contribution in legal claims for hypoxic brain injuries during birth.
When metal hip replacements go wrong
Hip replacement surgery is very common, restoring mobility and quality of life to thousands every year in the UK. It is recognised to be the most cost effective for the NHS in returning patients to productive lives. The components wearing surfaces may be metal, ceramic or plastic, and will often last over 20 to 25 years, or even longer for some people.
Is this the turning point for maternity care?
Concerns over NHS maternity care are very sadly seldom out of the news. As a lawyer who has specialised in birth injury claims over many years, it has been all too clear to me for a long time, that far too many women and babies, fail to receive anywhere close to adequate maternity care leading in some instances to devastating outcomes.
Why Fatigue of NHS Staff Matters and the Risk it Poses to Patient Safety
Fatigue within the NHS presents a significant risk to patient safety, yet in healthcare its consequences remain largely unrecognised despite the increasing demands on NHS workforces.
Litigation Friends
While we mostly associate dementia with the affect it can have on our memory, it can also affect our ability to think and communicate and our capacity to manage our own affairs. When undertaking legal proceedings, as solicitors, we have a duty to ensure that our clients have the mental capacity to give proper instructions to bring, or defend, a claim. Where our client does not have the necessary capacity, a Litigation Friend may be appointed
Brain injuries: the good, the bad and the inspiring
We are now in Action for Brain Injury week, run annually by the charity Headway to raise awareness and understanding of the different aspects of brain injury. The theme this year is ‘On a good day’ which aims to highlight the fluctuating and unpredictable nature of brain injury and the gap that can arise between someone’s capabilities on a good day versus a bad day. Headway wants people to see both sides of the story. It seeks to change behaviours and opinions towards those who might be having an ‘all-too-common bad day’.
Women’s Health Series 4: Cancer Claims
New research suggests that UK cancer cases have risen in women but fallen in men. Women’s cancers include gynaecological cancer (i.e. cervical, ovarian and vaginal cancers) and breast cancer. Here I look at the impacts of delays in diagnosis and treatment failures, provide some guidance on bringing a medical negligence claim and consider why there is hope for the future with new technologies.
Women’s Health Series: 3. Hysterectomy Claims
A lack of awareness and understanding appears to exist when it comes to women’s reproductive health conditions, and the diagnosis and treatment of hysterectomies is no exception to this.
In this blog we will be discussing where negligence can occur in relation to the treatment of hysterectomies, from initial misdiagnoses to surgical errors.
Women’s Health Series: 2. Endometriosis, Pelvic Inflammatory Disease and Fertility Claims
Endometriosis and Pelvic Inflammatory Disease (PID) are two conditions which affect a large number of women every year, and can have devastating effects on fertility and well-being, but frustratingly continue to experience long delays in diagnosis.
Share insightLinkedIn X Facebook Email to a friend Print