BAME and #BLACKLIVESMATTER

The silent threat of unconscious race discrimination in the workplace

28 September 2020

Throughout recent events which have seen an increased awareness of the Black Lives Matter movement and issues of race equality, there has been a lot of discussion around our biases and how we can all do work to unlearn the negative stereotypes that occupy our minds and affect how we see and react to others. Most people know that conscious acts of overt racism in the workplace are unlawful and, thankfully, such occurrences are rare.  But what about the less obvious and sometimes unconscious discriminatory behaviours in the workplace? What are they?  What problems do they cause and what steps can we take to overcome them?

 

What is unconscious bias and what is its effect?

Unconscious bias relates to social stereotypes that we hold about groups of people outside our conscious awareness. These are often incompatible with our conscious values, however, they still affect our thought processes and the decisions that we make, especially when making quick decisions.

There are various categories of unconscious bias.  Those most relevant to the workplace include:

  • affinity bias: where one feels an affinity or connection with another person because they have had similar life experiences to them. They may have been to the same university, or grown up in the same area, or they may even know one of the parents/family members of the other person. Affinity bias can easily lead to favouring someone – for recruitment or promotion, for example - purely because they are more like you; and
  • confirmation bias:  where one draws conclusions about others and their situation based on their own personal beliefs and biases and look for behaviours/traits which ’confirm’ those biases.  For example, a person may form an initial view about a job applicant based on attributes irrelevant to the role they are applying for (their name, where they live or which school they attended, for example).  Those opinions follow through into the interview and later stages of the recruitment process and may result in the interviewer steering questions and interpreting the answers given in a manner that confirms that initial (biased) opinion.

These biases can impact negatively on any minority group and in any scenario but, focussing on race and the employment context here, they can form a barrier to having a diverse workforce and inclusive working environment.  This in turn can result in a loss of talent for employers as BAME employees (if they make it through the recruitment process in the first place), may not feel comfortable in the workplace, or feel that their identity and heritage may prevent them progressing within the organisation.

Ensuring you have a diverse workforce is best achieved by making sure that decisions about recruitment and promotion are made by a diverse group of people.  If all of the senior members of staff, Human Resources (HR) department and decision-makers in an organisation are from a similar racial, ethnic or socio-economic background, there is a much higher risk of unconscious bias occurring and causing a barrier to diversity and inclusion in the workplace generally.  It is therefore important to ensure diversity at all levels in an organisation and, at the very least, to educate all staff about unconscious bias.

What are micro-aggressions?

Micro-aggressions are brief and common -verbal, behavioural, and environmental indignities, whether intentional or unintentional (sometimes even well-meaning), which communicate hostile, derogatory, or negative slights and insults to the receiver of those comments.

One example of a micro-aggression which often occurs in the workplace, is making sweeping generalisations about black people or other ethnic minority groups, or not “being able” to tell people of a certain ethnic group apart.  

Turning to another example, it is common for BAME people to be asked where they are from.  If/when the person being questioned states that they are British, or from London (for example), this often leads to further questioning, the undercurrent being that the first answer given is not adequate or accurate.  The initial question is usually posed to enquire about the heritage of the BAME person and could be entirely innocent.  Some may ask this question believing that they are showing a genuine interest in the individual.  However, it is a question often loaded with negativity.

The first issue is that the question may indicate to the receiver that the asker perceives them as “other” and that because they are not white, they are not “from here”.  This in turn can have the effect of the recipient of the question feeling that they do not belong, or are not accepted.  From personal experience, I will often be asked where I am from, to which my response is, Leeds. The asker often repeats the question in various tones (and the situation can become uncomfortable), until I finally explain that my mother’s parents are Polish and my father is Iranian. In short, my “Britishness” is not accepted, and therefore I have to clarify my answer to the asker’s satisfaction.

Such questions could be asked with innocent intentions, but given how they can be perceived and the negative impact that may have, one should think twice before asking them.  If you have a genuine interest in someone’s ethnic origin, before asking about it, consider whether it is relevant or appropriate in the context.  This can be particularly problematic in the workplace, especially if – as is often the case - those questioned are all of BAME origin and the white people in the room are not asked anything similar. In those circumstances, the people questioned may immediately feel that they are being singled out and a statement is effectively being made to them (and everyone else in the room), that they are different or do not belong. 

Another example of a micro-aggression that may occur in the workplace is commenting on, with surprise, a BAME person's articulateness.  Although seemingly a compliment (and may indeed be intended as such), this comment demonstrates that the commentator may have been affected by the negative stereotype that BAME people are less educated and less well-spoken than white people.  Again, this micro-aggression acts as an immediate indication that the asker sees the BAME person as different/other. Furthermore, this micro-aggression can act as an unnecessary and offensive reminder to the BAME person of the statistical truth that BAME people are starkly underrepresented in certain professions and senior positions. This is not due to natural ability or talent, but is a result of the cumulative effect of social and economic disadvantage which members of BAME communities are disproportionately affected by, as well as the effects of unconscious bias in employment practices. 

Is this unlawful discrimination?

For the reasons already mentioned, unconscious bias and micro-aggressions can act as a barrier to BAME people making it into a workplace in the first place.  However, they can also create a negative and uncomfortable environment for those that are there and prevent progression.  This clearly translates into the culture of the organisation.

Although subtle – and more difficult to identify – unconscious bias and micro-aggressions are no less serious than overt racism.  

The Equality Act 2010 protects people from direct and indirect race discrimination, harassment and victimisation because of race.  If one employee discriminates against another, the employer will be liable unless it has taken reasonable steps to prevent such conduct from taking place.  The offending employee may also be personally liable for their actions.

Harassment, victimisation and, possibly, indirect discrimination are the most relevant possible claims in the context of unconscious bias. 

Harassment occurs where a person engages in unwanted conduct towards another related to race, which has the purpose or effect of violating that person's dignity, or of creating an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating or offensive environment for them.  Micro-aggressions – perhaps even in the form of banter and inappropriate use of language – can amount to subtle forms of bullying.  The discomfort and intimidating environment this can cause can clearly fall within the definition of harassment and leave the employer (and perpetrators), exposed to claims. 

Victimisation occurs where a job applicant or employee is subjected to a detriment because they have made or intend to make a complaint of race discrimination.  This can occur where an individual calls out what they deem to be inappropriate language or behaviour but is then subjected to detrimental treatment, perhaps by being accused of being “too sensitive”, or a trouble-maker”.  They may even be overlooked for promotion or given negative feedback about their people skills in their next appraisal as a result of their complaint.  This can be particularly sensitive in situations where the perpetrator is in a more senior position than the person making the complaint.  

How to address the silent threat

So what can employers and individuals do to address the silent threat of unconscious bias in the workplace?  Here are some ideas:

How is your organisation doing? Ask your employees how they feel about the workplace environment and how inclusive it is.  This can be done by sending out surveys to staff which may be completed anonymously.  Exit interviews and feedback forms are also a good way of obtaining information from individuals regarding perceived issues on equality and diversity and identifying any problems.  People who are about to leave may be more open than those still working for the company and, seeking their feedback may assist in addressing issues to prevent further loss of talent because of issues linked to discrimination.

Training and beyond: Raising understanding and awareness through suitable equality and diversity and unconscious bias training is a great place to start – and indeed vital to have at all levels of the organisation - but training alone will not drive change.  Having an internal group or employee committee dedicated to tackling racism and promoting diversity and encouraging conversations about race can make a real difference to the culture within a workplace. It is important that any such group is positively promoted within the organisation and supported by senior management.

Encourage people to speak up:  Employees should be encouraged to speak up against racism and to raise concerns in accordance with the relevant internal policies and procedures of the employer (anti-bullying and harassment policy, for example).  Any such allegations or complaints should be taken seriously and addressed fully to give employees confidence that their concerns will be properly addressed if they come forward.  It is also particularly important that white employees call out racism and inappropriate behaviour or language in support of their BAME colleagues.  As recent commentary on racism has been emphasising, not being racist is not enough to challenge the status quo; it is important for there to be BAME allies who are actively anti-racist and speak up, as it is that that will drive change.

Recruitment: Many organisations have already taken to operating name blind and university blind recruitment processes. This is a good way of minimising the risk of unconscious bias in recruitment so that jobs are offered based purely on merit and suitability for the role.  Positive action can also be utilised to help employers work towards a more diverse workforce and better BAME representation, although this is not without its challenges (as explained by our colleagues, Nikola Southern and Clodagh Hogan in their recent blog on positive action). 

Personal work: Everyone has a part to play in tackling the silent threat of unconscious bias.  Employees should be encouraged to educate themselves on unconscious bias, micro-aggressions and issues regarding race and equality.  Education can mean reading, watching documentaries and, at the most basic level, listening to the thoughts and experiences of BAME colleagues with regard to such matters and thinking carefully before saying something that may cause offence (albeit inadvertently).  Employers can help by encouraging discourse and sharing reading lists and information.

It is natural for people to find it easier to relate to those who are most like themselves or who come from similar backgrounds.  However, we also have something to gain from creating a diverse work environment where everyone feels supported and encouraged.  It is therefore important to ensure that the silent threat of the unconscious bias that may exist in a workplace or its processes are identified and challenged, not only to minimise the risk of legal claims, but also to make sure that they do not hinder progress towards a diverse, inclusive and, ultimately, happier and more productive workforce.

Our Black Lives Matter/BAME blog series

As a firm, we have had many discussions about Black Lives Matter and how we can make a difference to the movement. We wanted to do more than just put out a statement of support, we wanted to take substantive action to address the inequalities faced by Black people and other ethnic minorities. Over the coming weeks, we will be publishing a series of blogs from our varying practice areas highlighting what we are doing, how you can make a difference and shining a light on the issues.

Our Diversity and Inclusion group is working hard with Human Resources and the Management Team to effect change through methods such as training and reviewing recruitment practices.  We have implemented a lot of change but we recognise we have more to do and we are always looking to make improvements as a firm.  We all have respective roles to play in advocating for issues of inequality and we hope our blogs give you some inspiration as to how you can make a change.

 

 

Further Information

If you would like any further information or advice about the issues explored in this blog, please contact Nadjia Zychowicz or another member of our employment team.

 

 

About the authors

Nadjia has versatile experience supporting corporate and education sector clients as well as senior executives in a broad range of employment law matters.

Özlem is very experienced in giving training talks on topical employment law issues and, as a member of the Employment Lawyers' Association (ELA), has participated in preparing ELA’s response to Government consultations on various issues.

 

Latest blogs & news

Black History Month – why do I care?

Celebrating this year’s Black History Month (BHM) with is powerful campaign, “Proud to Be”, is an apt time for us all to consider why we (should) care about Black history and culture.

Redundancy and negotiating an exit package during the pandemic

Coronavirus is having a serious impact on businesses and the global economy. Sadly, many businesses have been impacted to the extent that they have or will have to put cost-cutting measures in place. For some individuals this will result in their role being put at risk of redundancy.

Preparation for Public Inquiries - Webinar Summary

In light of the announcement that an independent inquiry into the Government’s handling of the coronavirus pandemic will begin in spring 2022, Kingsley Napley hosted a webinar last week on the theme of Preparing for Public Inquiries in conjunction with Blackstone Chambers and FTI Consulting. For anyone who missed this event, a recording is available here (LINK) and we have also prepared the summary below.  

Black History Month - The Power of Diverse Storytelling

When Black History Month was established in the United States, over a century ago, it was intended as a way to celebrate and give national recognition to black stories and perspectives.

At Kingsley Napley, we believe in the power of diverse and representative stories and we have found some wonderful and effective ways to share them that you might like to try too.

Why it’s time for youth mobility visas for EU nationals

The Youth Mobility Scheme allows employers to access younger workers from countries such as India and Iceland for two years. With skills shortages afflicting critical sectors, now might be the time for the government to consider a youth visa agreement with the EU.

Back to the office? - Your legal rights on returning to work during COVID-19

In revised guidance first published in July, the Government stated that it is no longer instructing people to work from home if they can.  In line with that, many employers have planned and begun implementing a return to the workplace.  However, as the latest figures and the Government’s recently published Autumn and Winter Plan seem to indicate, it is clear that the risk of contracting COVID-19 will continue to be a genuine and serious one for some time.

Covid and post-Brexit immigration rules serve up a recipe for disaster in the hospitality sector

From being the centrepiece of England’s post-Covid recovery with ‘eat out to help out’, the hospitality sector is now struggling to rebuild after lockdowns, furlough and rising food prices. At the same time many restaurants, cafes and pubs are coming up against the hard realities of a post-Brexit immigration policy and discovering what it means for their business.

Proposed changes to the flexible working regime

Earlier this year it was announced that the Government had plans to consult on changes to our flexible working regime. The Government’s Consultation Paper has now been published and illustrates the Government’s intentions regarding how flexible working rights will operate in future.

Is a personality clash in the Boardroom a fair reason for dismissal?

A recent case has highlighted a trend that that we have seen over recent years, with Employment Tribunals finding that the dismissal of a senior executive can be fair where there has been a breakdown in relations amongst a management team and one director / executive is considered to be more at fault (Moore v Phoenix Product Development Ltd EAT/0070/20).  Also, the procedural requirements for such dismissals may be more limited, in this case, the fact that no right of appeal was offered did not render the dismissal unfair.

Celebrating Bisexuality Visibility Day!

The visibility of the “B” in our LGBTQ+ umbrella is marked every year on 23 September. At Kingsley Napley, we are proud to have bisexual members of our LGBTQ+ and Allies Network and strive for everyone to feel like they can be themselves and bring their whole selves to work. Outside KN, and in this year alone, Robin has come out as bisexual in the new Batman comic, more awareness has been raised about bisexuality with celebrities, such as Megan Fox, Lily Cole, speaking out and there is more representation of bisexual people in mainstream shows, such as Sex Education, Brooklyn Nine-Nine.

"Was it something I said?” Whistleblowing during the pandemic

You may be surprised to learn that, without realising it, you may be a whistleblower. If you are a manager, you could easily come across a situation in which you are expected to manage (or even dismiss) a whistleblower, without anyone warning you of the dangers. 

 

What rights do employees accused of bullying have?

Employers have a duty to take reasonable care of the health and safety of their staff and this includes those facing such allegations, says Bina Patel

The “Great Resignation”? Things to consider for employers and employees

In recent weeks, a number of commentators have predicted the “Great Resignation”—a mass exodus of employees leaving their jobs following the wake-up call the pandemic has afforded them. Microsoft research has indicated that almost half of the worldwide workforce is ready to resign this year, with just under 40% of UK and Irish workers saying they are ready to quit. Many have had cause to re-evaluate their careers during COVID and with lockdown restrictions set to ease further, people are considering their options. If the “Great Resignation” is upon us, there are a few things employers and employees should bear in mind.

World Suicide Prevention Day

To mark Suicide Prevention Day and raise awareness of the prevalence of deaths by suicide in the UK, Kingsley Napley is set to host a mental health panel discussion on 10 September 2021.

The National Disability Strategy: the most comprehensive, concerted, cross-government plan ever. Is it really?

On the 28 July 2021, the Government unveiled the highly anticipated National Disability Strategy (‘the strategy’). Pledged in the Government’s 2019 manifesto, the aim is to “improve the everyday lives of disabled people”. The Prime Minister described the strategy as the most comprehensive, concerted, cross-government plan relating to disability ever. A bold claim, but is it justified?

Back to work – where exactly does this leave employers in the aftermath of “Freedom Day” ?

“Freedom Day”, and what it actually means in practice, is not proving to be as straightforward as some had hoped (and arguably as the Government had initially led the business community to believe).  Employers can be forgiven for feeling confused as to what is expected of them and what they should be doing in terms of bringing their employees back into the workplace. We are by no means at the end of the debate, but we summarise below, the latest developments

Kingsley Napley wishes our Muslim Community Eid Mubarak as Eid al-Adha is celebrated around the world.

Whilst our Muslim colleagues and friends celebrate over communal meals and prayer, it is also a time for us at Kingsley Napley to reflect on the importance of observing and respecting the cultural and religious differences of others. We are motivated to make Kingsley Napley a place which is not only diverse, but also inclusive, where all our people feel able to bring their true selves to work.

Disciplining an employee for posting racist comments online

We have seen examples of people being ‘outed’ for posting racist comments online by individual bystanders who have been able to find their LinkedIn profiles and then contact relevant employers calling for the employee in question to lose their job.  Unfortunately, this is nothing new. But what can an organisation do in these circumstances, if it wants to demonstrate that it stands against racism and discrimination?

Back to the workplace – the new guidance and key considerations for employers

With lockdown restrictions moving to “Stage 4” of the Government’s roadmap to recovery, one of the key questions will be what this means with regard to returning to the workplace and, in a recent article, we considered the rights of employees on this issue.

Law firm partner’s profit share allocation was a reasonable exercise of discretion

Most disputes between partners of professional services firms are settled either through confidential negotiations or arbitration.  A public resolution of the matter through a full hearing and reported judgment is a rare occurrence. A recent example of such a case involving an ex-partner of a law firm is a useful reminder that it is difficult to challenge profit share or bonus decisions as an irrational exercise of discretion.

R.E.A.C.H. & Allies bulletin board

R.E.A.C.H. & Allies bulletin board

What is Hair Discrimination ? – Kingsley Napley joins the Halo Code

In this REACH podcast hosted by Shannett Thompson Partner in Regulatory, Shannett discusses joining the Halo code, the topic of hair discrimination and what hair discrimination means to them with Kingsley Napley employees from across the firm

Listen to the podcast

Shannett Thompson and Donna Cummings delve into issues around BAME recruitment

In this episode, Shannett Thompson and Donna Cummings delve into issues around BAME recruitment.

Listen to the podcast

Positive representation in the tech industry with Ash Cooper

In this podcast episode of KN BAME Talks for Black History Month 2020, Ash Cooper, IT Director at Kingsley Napley, talks about positive representation and his career in the tech industry.

Listen to the podcast

Shannett Thompson speaks at Urban Lawyers Careers Conf​erence November 2019​

Urban Lawyers works to makes the law more accessible as a career to marginalised groups and improve social mobility and diversity in the legal profession.​

View Urban Lawyers CC 2019 site

Film screening of The Hard Stop

Attended by KN employees and the Stop and Search Legal Project.

View SSLP's site

Intersecti​onality P​​er-spective - Celebrating Black History Month

Kingsley Napley's BAME and LGBTQ & Allies networks hosted a series of talks at London's Arboretum on 16 October 2019. The focus of the event was to open up the conversation about intersectionality, whilst shining a light on the progress of Black History Month in Britain. The speakers were Charles Irvine, Anthony Francis, Debo Nwauzu and Dr S Chelvan.

INTERNATIONAL WOMEN'S DAY 2020: BAME heroines who exemplify #EachforEqual

Drawing from the strength of shared experiences, women around the world have been uniting in common struggles such as sexual and domestic violence, pay inequality, reproductive autonomy and climate change. While great leaps forward have been made and women-led movements have been gaining unprecedented attention and support , minority ethnic women are often left behind as these struggles are compounded with the intersection of their race/ethnicity and gender.

View blog post

BAME webinar: Challenges faced at work

Recorded Monday 3 December 2018.

View webinar

Holocaust Memorial Day 2020: “Stand Together”

Holocaust Memorial Day, on 27 January 2020, will mark 75 years since the liberation of Auschwitz, where more than a million people perished in gas chambers, most of them Jews. The day is internationally marked in remembrance of the victims of the Holocaust and other appalling acts of genocide, including later atrocities in Cambodia, Rwanda, Bosnia and Darfur, and to recognise that the lessons of the Holocaust are still relevant, especially at a time when racism and extremism is on the rise across Europe.

View blog post

BAME book club: The Good Immigrant

Our most recent book is by Nikesh Shukla.

Kingsley Napley Diversity and Inclusion Statistics 2019

Download report

Share insightLinkedIn Twitter Facebook Email to a friend Print

Email this page to a friend

We welcome views and opinions about the issues raised in this blog. Should you require specific advice in relation to personal circumstances, please use the form on the contact page.

Leave a comment

You may also be interested in:

Skip to content Home About Us Insights Services Contact Accessibility