BAME and #BLACKLIVESMATTER

Racial inequality in mental healthcare

20 July 2020

As a firm, we have had many discussions about Black Lives Matter and how we can make a difference to the movement. In the sixth blog in our series,  Sevim and Satvir want to shine a light on areas that are often overlooked because they relate to the most vulnerable and least represented. They look at racial inequality in mental healthcare and explore the reasons for this inequality.

 

Government statistics reveal that “profound inequalities exist for people from ethnic minority communities in accessing mental health treatment, their experience of care and their mental health outcome”. The disparity in the standard and type of care and treatment provided, particularly to individuals from black African and Caribbean communities, in comparison to their white counterparts, is stark and very worrying. In the wake of the Black Lives Matter movement, we share our thoughts on this disturbing reality.

Recent research and government statistics reveal:

  • Black people are four times more likely to be detained under the Mental Health Act than their white counterparts.
  • Out of the 16 specific ethnic groups, black Caribbean people had the highest rate of detention out of all ethnic groups (excluding groups labelled ‘Other’)
  • Black and white men experience similar rates of common mental health problems.  However, black men experience psychosis ten times more frequently than white men.  Despite this, white people are twice more likely to receive treatment for their mental health problems than black people are.
  • In terms of routes to treatment, people of black African and Caribbean heritage are 40% more likely than white British counterparts to come into contact with mental health services through the police or criminal justice system, rather than their GP or talking therapies. 
  • People of black African and Caribbean heritage are less likely to receive psychological therapies and more likely to be compulsorily admitted for treatment in a medium to high secure wards, and subject to seclusion or restraint. 
  • Black patients are subject to Community Treatment Orders at eight times the rate of white patients in comparison to their representation in the general population.  Community Treatment Orders are a legal measure that allows mental health teams to impose compulsory supervision on patients and patients also have to adhere to specified conditions. If the Community Treatment Order is not adhered to, the patient risks being admitted back to hospital.
  • A disproportionate number of people from black African or Caribbean heritage experience deaths while in custody or under mental healthcare.  An example of this includes the death of Olaseni Lewis, who was aged 23 when he was voluntarily admitted to Bethlem Royal Hospital for mental health treatment in August 2010.  When Mr Lewis became agitated medical staff called the police. Over a period of 30 to 40 minutes eleven police officers subjected him to restraint for two prolonged periods – 10 and 20 minutes. Mr Lewis was held down, face first, on the bed and then the floor. He died as a result of his brain being starved of oxygen.  An Inquest was held into Mr Lewis’s death found multiple failings and that police officers contributed to his death.  The court ruled that “the excessive force, pain compliance techniques and multiple mechanical restraints were disproportionate and unreasonable”. 

The government carried out an Independent Review of the Mental Health Act, which was published in December 2018. The Review concluded that a disproportionate number of people from black and minority ethnicity backgrounds are detained under the Mental Health Act and the use of the Mental Health Act appears to vary between different ethnic groups. The Review was particularly concerned by the “excessively poorer experiences and outcomes of individuals from black African and Caribbean communities”. 

So why is there such a disparity? The answer is multi-factorial. For many years individuals from black African and Caribbean communities have been subjected to second class treatment which has led to fear and mistrust of public services. Dr Frank Keating in his report Breaking the Circles of Fear, concluded that black people have a strongly grounded fear of mistrust and therefore resist seeking help. Dr Jacqui Dyer MBE, Mental Health Equalities Champion, expanded on this further and found many individuals in the black community believe that if you seek help from mental health services, you don’t go for recovery but go there to die. What is supposed to be a therapeutic recovery process is perceived as chemical and physical containment.

In addition to the above, the Independent Review acknowledged that racism experienced by individuals in everyday life compounds already poor experiences and outcomes from health services. Research has shown a direct link between health inequalities and racism.  Socioeconomic factors also contribute to health inequality such as inequalities in housing, local neighbourhoods, education and employment.

Research has also shown that those making clinical decisions may hold racially biased views against those from minority ethnic backgrounds, which will directly impact upon a clinician’s decision regarding treatment options. The unconscious bias of those that are responsible for treating patients with mental health conditions lead to excessive use of compulsory detention, seclusion and restraints.

The government’s Independent Review is a step forward in recognising the inequality provided to minority ethnic groups in the treatment of mental health problems. However, there is a lot that needs to be done to tackle racial prejudice and unconscious bias in order to ensure mental health services are provided equally and fairly.

OUR BLACK LIVES MATTER / BAME BLOG SERIES

As a firm, we have had many discussions about Black Lives Matter and how we can make a difference to the movement. We wanted to do more than just put out a statement of support, we wanted to take substantive action to address the inequalities faced by Black people and other ethnic minorities. Over the coming weeks, we will be publishing a series of blogs from our varying practice areas highlighting what we are doing, how you can make a difference and shining a light on the issues.

Our Diversity and Inclusion group is working hard with Human Resources and the Management Team to effect change through methods such as training and reviewing recruitment practices.  We have implemented a lot of change but we recognise we have more to do and we are always looking to make improvements as a firm.  We all have respective roles to play in advocating for issues of inequality and we hope our blogs give you some inspiration as to how you can make a change.

About the authors

Sevim Ahmet is an Associate in the Medical Negligence and Personal Injury team department and an experienced specialist in clinical negligence claims of all types, often acting for bereaved families or on behalf of children and adults who have suffered permanent and profound injuries.

Satvir Sokhi specialises in clinical negligence and has experience of working with clients who have sustained a range of injuries, including brain injuriesinjuries arising from birth, orthopaedic injuries and gastrointestinal injuries.

 

 

BAME bulletin board

BAME bulletin board

Positive representation in the tech industry with Ash Cooper

In this podcast episode of KN BAME Talks for Black History Month 2020, Ash Cooper, IT Director at Kingsley Napley, talks about positive representation and his career in the tech industry.

Listen to the podcast

Shannett Thompson speaks at Urban Lawyers Careers Conf​erence November 2019​

Urban Lawyers works to makes the law more accessible as a career to marginalised groups and improve social mobility and diversity in the legal profession.​

View Urban Lawyers CC 2019 site

Film screening of The Hard Stop

Attended by KN employees and the Stop and Search Legal Project.

View SSLP's site

Intersecti​onality P​​er-spective - Celebrating Black History Month

Kingsley Napley's BAME and LGBTQ & Allies networks hosted a series of talks at London's Arboretum on 16 October 2019. The focus of the event was to open up the conversation about intersectionality, whilst shining a light on the progress of Black History Month in Britain. The speakers were Charles Irvine, Anthony Francis, Debo Nwauzu and Dr S Chelvan.

INTERNATIONAL WOMEN'S DAY 2020: BAME heroines who exemplify #EachforEqual

Drawing from the strength of shared experiences, women around the world have been uniting in common struggles such as sexual and domestic violence, pay inequality, reproductive autonomy and climate change. While great leaps forward have been made and women-led movements have been gaining unprecedented attention and support , minority ethnic women are often left behind as these struggles are compounded with the intersection of their race/ethnicity and gender.

View blog post

BAME webinar: Challenges faced at work

Recorded Monday 3 December 2018.

View webinar

Holocaust Memorial Day 2020: “Stand Together”

Holocaust Memorial Day, on 27 January 2020, will mark 75 years since the liberation of Auschwitz, where more than a million people perished in gas chambers, most of them Jews. The day is internationally marked in remembrance of the victims of the Holocaust and other appalling acts of genocide, including later atrocities in Cambodia, Rwanda, Bosnia and Darfur, and to recognise that the lessons of the Holocaust are still relevant, especially at a time when racism and extremism is on the rise across Europe.

View blog post

BAME book club: The Good Immigrant

Our most recent book is by Nikesh Shukla.

Kingsley Napley Diversity and Inclusion Statistics 2019

Download report

Share insightLinkedIn Twitter Facebook Email to a friend Print

Email this page to a friend

We welcome views and opinions about the issues raised in this blog. Should you require specific advice in relation to personal circumstances, please use the form on the contact page.

Leave a comment

You may also be interested in:

Skip to content Home About Us Insights Services Contact Accessibility