Environmental Law Quarterly Update - Q1 2021

7 April 2021

This quarterly environmental law update provides a summary of a cross section of news stories in the period Jan 2021 - March 2021.


January

JOINT UNIT FOR WASTE CRIME: A ‘SUCCESSFUL FIRST YEAR’

On 18 January 2021, almost a year to the day from its launch, the Joint Unit for Waste Crime reported that it had “wasted no time in sharing intelligence, identifying illegal activity and conducting numerous operations to disrupt illegal activities, leading to arrests of suspected waste criminals and bringing them to justice”. With the stated intention to enter 2021 “stronger and more determined than ever to tackle those engaged in serious and organised waste crime”, our prediction that interventions and enforcement action increasing in this area is likely to become a reality.

 

18 MONTH PRISON SENTENCE FOR STOCKPILING AND BURNING WASTE

On 25 January 2021 Mr Stephen Lack, trading as Abbey Skips, was sentenced to 18 months’ imprisonment following a guilty plea to breaching environmental regulations pertaining to the depositing, treatment and storage of waste contrary to Regulations 12 and 38(1)(a) of the Environmental Permitting (England and Wales) Regulations 2016. Mr Lack had repeatedly stockpiled and burned waste without the necessary Environment Agency permits in offending which spanned a decade. Following court enforcement in April 2019 in which he was handed a 6 months suspended sentence, he was arrested within a month for further illegal activities. After being released on bail, he was again arrested in September 2020 for further illegal burning and burial of waste. In addition to the custodial sentence, Mr Lack was given a remediation order to clear the land where the offence took place by January 2022, which the Environment Agency estimate could cost £750,000, and ordered to pay costs of £12,500.

 

February

THAMES WATER FINED £2.3M FOR RIVER POLLUTION

On 26 February 2021 Thames Water was sentenced to a fine of £2.3m and ordered to pay costs of almost £90,000. The fine relates to the leakage of untreated sewage into a stream which led to the River Thames between 21 and 24 April 2016. This caused significant environmental damage killing 1,144 fish and other water life. This sentence followed earlier fines for Thames Water of £1.8m in 2019 for sewage pollution in the Cotswolds and a record breaking £20m in 2017 for six separate water pollution incidents resulting in the spillage of 1.9bn litres of untreated sewage into the Thames. See our article for LexisNexis here.

 

March

HIGH STREET BRANDS ACCEPT ENFORCEMENT UNDERTAKINGS FOR FAILING TO COMPLY WITH PACKAGING WASTE REGULATIONS

On 3 March 2021 four high street brands, Zara Home, Bershka, Pull & Bear and Massimo Dutti, all owned by the same Spanish parent company, Inditex S.A., agreed to enforcement undertakings (an enforceable promise to do agreed actions) with the Environment Agency after failing to meet their obligations as ‘Packaging Producers’ for a number of years. As companies handling 50 tonnes of packaging a year, with a turnover of over £2 million, they are defined as ‘obligated’ packaging producers and are therefore required to register with the Environment Agency or a packaging compliance scheme. They are also required to meet their responsibilities for recycling of waste packaging each year. As part of the enforcement undertakings the companies were required to put in place additional compliance measures, make contributions of £26,000 to two environmental charities and pay the Environment Agency’s costs.

 

THE IVORY ACT 2018: CONSULTATION OPENED

In advance of the Ivory Act 2018 coming into force, on 9 March 2021 the Department for Environmental Food & Rural Affairs launched an eight-week consultation on its proposed implementation. When it commences, the Act will introduce a near total ban on dealing in ivory (which includes buying, selling, offering to arrange to buy or sell, keeping it for sale or hire, exporting it from the UK for sale or hire or importing it into the UK for sale or hire). It will be an offence under s.12 of the Act, punishable of up to five years’ imprisonment, to breach the prohibition or cause or facilitate the prohibition to be breached, where you know or suspect (or ought to know or suspect) that an item is, ivory, is made of ivory or has ivory in it.

 

ENVIRONMENT BILL: CONSULTATION ON THE DRAFT POLICY STATEMENT ON ENVIRONMENTAL PRINCIPLES

Within the current draft of the Environment Bill (which is currently at the report stage) there is a duty, at s.16, for the Secretary of State to prepare a ‘policy statement on environmental principles’ which, under s.18, Ministers to have due regard to when making policy. On 10 March 2021 the Department for Environmental Food & Rural Affairs opened a consultation on the current draft statement. The statement is required to include the following five key environmental principles: the ‘integration principle’ (embedding environmental protection in fields of policy which have an impact on the environment; the ‘prevention principle’ (prevent, reduce or mitigate harm); the ‘rectification at source principle’ (tackling environmental at its origin where it cannot be prevented); the ‘polluter pays principle’ (mitigation and compensation the responsibility of those who cause pollution or damage the environment); and the ‘precautionary principle’ (the inability to rely on scientific uncertainty as a reason for delaying cost-effective measures to prevent environmental degradation where there is a threat of serious/irreversible environmental damage).

 

NEW LAWS TO REDUCE SEWAGE FROM STORM OVERFLOWS

On 29 March 2021 the government confirmed it would introduce new laws to reduce the sewage discharges from storm overflows, which act to prevent sewers becoming overloaded during wet weather and release diluted waste water into waterways. The new legal duties will require the government to publish a plan by September 2022 to reduce sewage discharges from storm overflows and to report to Parliament on progress implementing the plan. Water companies will also be required to publish data annually on storm overflow operation.

This announcement was followed by the publication of data by the Department for Environmental Food & Rural Affairs on 30 March 2021 which showed an increase in the frequency and duration of waste water discharges from storm overflows. The data collated from monitored storm overflows across the UK showed there were 403,171 incidents of sewage discharge into waterways in 2020, a 37% increase from 2019, and for a total duration of 3.1 million hours. This increase is in part due to an increase in the number of storm overflows which are monitored by the Environment Agency, up to 12,092 in 2020 from 8,276 in 2019.

 

EU COURT RULING ON UK AIR POLLUTION

On 4 March 2021 the Court of Justice of the European Union ruled that the UK has “systematically and persistently” exceeded legal limits on dangerous nitrogen dioxide across 16 urban areas in the UK since 2010. The CJEU further held that the UK had failed to adopt appropriate measures to ensure compliance with strict limits for nitrogen dioxide and failed in its legal obligations to implement plans to tackle this problem in the shortest possible time. This ruling came after an infringement procedure was initiated by the European Commission in 2014 in respect of the UK’s failure to implement the EU Directive on ambient air quality and cleaner air for Europe.

This ruling follows the findings of an inquest into the tragic death of nine-year old Ella Kissi-Debrah from Lewisham, London, in 2013 in which the Coroner concluded that she had “died of asthma contributed to by exposure to excessive air pollution”. These Coroner’s findings, delivered on 16 December 2020, became the first in the UK in which air pollution exposure has been listed as a medical cause of death. It was held that between 2010 and 2013, during which time Ella’s asthma was exacerbated, there was a recognised failure to reduce nitrogen dioxide levels to within the limits set by EU and domestic law which possibly contributed to her death.

 

Further Information

For further information on the issues raised in this blog post, please contact a member of our Health, Safety & Environment team.

about the authors

Sophie Wood is a Senior Associate in the Criminal Litigation team with extensive experience in advising corporate and individual clients involved in a wide range of internal, criminal and regulatory investigations. Sophie has acted for individuals and companies involved in investigations brought by the Environment Agency, Health and Safety Executive and local authorities, and is a member of the firm’s cross-practice Health, Safety and Environment Group.

Charlie Roe is a trainee solicitor currently in the Criminal Litigation team. Charlie joined Kingsley Napley in September 2019 as a trainee. Prior to joining Kingsley Napley, Charlie worked at a leading London litigation firm as a paralegal in their Personal Injury and Employment departments. Charlie read History and Politics at Newcastle University. After working in the charity sector he completed the Graduate Diploma in Law and Legal Practice Course at the University of Law, Moorgate.

 

Latest blogs & news

Environmental Law Quarterly Update - Q3 2021

This quarterly environmental law update provides a summary of a cross-section of news stories in the period July 2021 - September 2021. 

Vue Cinema Chain fined following death of cinema-goer

On 20 July 2021 Vue Entertainment Ltd (‘Vue’) was fined £750,000 and ordered to pay costs of £130,000 following a fatal accident at the Star City cinema in Birmingham on 9 March 2018.

Record fine of £90 million for Southern Water

On 9 July 2021 Southern Water Services Ltd (SWS) was fined £90 million, to be paid out of company operating profits, in what was the largest fine ever imposed on a water company.

Environmental Law Quarterly Update - Q2 2021

This quarterly environmental law update provides a summary of a cross-section of news stories in the period April 2021 - June 2021. 

R v Wood Treatment Limited - corporate manslaughter and the challenge of proving causation

The recent case of R v Wood Limited Treatment highlights the problems faced by prosecution authorities in proving causation for the purposes of establishing criminal liability for corporate manslaughter.

Environmental Law Quarterly Update - Q1 2021

This quarterly environmental law update provides a summary of a cross section of news stories in the period Jan 2021 - March 2021. 

Arrests of care home workers following COVID-19 outbreaks: a review of criminal liability

In late February 2021 a news article reported that a care home worker had been arrested on suspicion of gross negligence manslaughter after a patient died of COVID-19. In late March 2021, two further care home workers were arrested on suspicion of wilful neglect. We look at how those working in care homes can potentially face criminal liability in respect of COVID-19 cases.

Thames Water fined for “entirely foreseeable” pollution

Thames Water was sentenced on Friday 26 February 2021 to a fine of £2.3m and ordered to pay costs of almost £90,000. The case is noteworthy both because of the level of the fine imposed and because the Environment Agency (“EA”) uses criminal prosecutions as a means of enforcement relatively rarely.

You are what you package your food in - Food Standards Agency consults on changes to food contact materials offences

On 4 November 2020, the Food Standards Agency (“FSA”) launched a consultation seeking views on proposed changes to the offences for non-compliance under the Materials and Articles in Contact with Food (England) Regulations 2012 (the “Regulations”).

Return to sender: Illegal waste exports are returned to the UK

On 28 October 2020 the Environment Agency (“EA”) announced that a consignment of 21 waste containers, which were illegally shipped to Sri Lanka in 2017, had been successfully returned to their point of origin in the UK.

Care home ordered to pay £167,670 for health and safety breaches

Sentinel Health Care Limited has pleaded guilty to two charges of failing to provide safe care and treatment, resulting in avoidable harm, to resident Andrew Clegg and a further charge of failing to provide safe care and treatment exposing other service users, to a significant risk of avoidable harm.

Crown Censure for the MoD after health and safety failings

On 29 September 2020 it was announced that the Ministry of Defence (“MoD”) had accepted a Crown Censure from the Health and Safety Executive (“HSE”) after a 26 year old marine died during a training exercise.

Directors disqualified following history of health and safety and waste law breaches

Brother and sister Mark and Rachel Penfold were directors of a waste management company. In February 2016 an employee of the business suffered a serious injury when his arm was caught in a conveyer he was operating whilst at work. The Health and Safety Executive prosecuted the company and both individuals under the Provision and Use of Work Equipment Regulations 1998 (PUWER). 

Companies in hot water: environmental performance deteriorates further

The Environment Agency’s (“EA”) 2 October 2020 annual report provides sober reading for the nine water and waste service companies operating in England. After the 2019 report’s finding that performance across the sector was already ‘unacceptable’, the 2020 report concluded that all, without exception, had continued to deteriorate.

The Fire Safety Bill: Extending the scope of the Fire Safety Order

On 1 October, the Fire Safety Bill had its second reading and debate in the House of Lords. The Bill is short but introduces important new measures.

Recycling firm charged with corporate manslaughter

West Midlands Police have announced that Alutrade Limited, a specialist recycler of aluminium, is to be charged with corporate manslaughter over the death of Stuart Towns in July 2017. The last conviction of a company for corporate manslaughter was in 2017.

COVID-19: Can you be prosecuted for opening your shop?

The Secretary of State for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy (“BEIS”), Alok Sharma, announced this week that non-essential shops will be allowed to open from 15 June. Mr Sharma also stated that if shops do not follow COVID-secure guidelines they could be subject to enforcement notices. What does this mean?

Returning to work and COVID-19: Could employers face health and safety prosecutions for infections in the workplace?

As we move through the phased easing of lockdown, employers and employees will be anxious to ensure that the return to the workplace does not exacerbate the risk of infection. Businesses do not want to find themselves falling foul of the law, and with news last month that the Health and Safety Executive (“HSE” – the body responsible for regulating and enforcing health and safety legislation) has been bolstered with £14m extra funding, it is more important than ever to manage the risks.

 

The Hackitt Review- Two years on

It is just over two years since the publication of Dame Hackitt’s Independent Review of Building Regulations and Fire Safety.  Following the Grenfell Tower fire in June 2017, the Government commissioned a report to make recommendations on the regulatory system covering high rise and complex buildings. 

The Notre-Dame Fire: safeguarding our historic buildings

The sad news on Monday evening that one of the world’s iconic historical buildings was engulfed in flames caused many to question whether other historical buildings around the world are vulnerable to the same fate.

Share insightLinkedIn Twitter Facebook Email to a friend Print

Email this page to a friend

We welcome views and opinions about the issues raised in this blog. Should you require specific advice in relation to personal circumstances, please use the form on the contact page.

Leave a comment

You may also be interested in:

Skip to content Home About Us Insights Services Contact Accessibility