E-Regulator: Ramjan v General Dental Council 2012 All ER (D) 109 (Feb)

1 March 2012

CASE COMMENTARY

When does treatment go from being simply incompetent to dishonest?

The appellant, a dentist in practice for over 30 years, appealed a decision to remove his name from the Dental Register due to a finding of dishonesty by the Professional Conduct Committee.

The original proceedings were in relation to a choice of treatment carried out by the appellant which was not clinically justified, without consent, causing irreparable and irreversible damage to the patient. The Committee found, having considered the test of dishonesty in Donkin v Law Society [2007] EWHC 414 (Admin (2007) 157 N.L.J, that the appellant had deliberately and dishonestly conducted the treatment.

The Committee concluded that the appellant posed an ongoing risk and found that his fitness to practise was impaired.

The appellant appealed on the basis that the finding of dishonesty had not been properly open to the committee and it did not have a proper basis for that conclusion.

The appeal was dismissed. The Committee had had the benefit of hearing from an expert who was unable to provide any explanation for the choice of treatment made by the appellant.  The choice of treatment constituted a serious professional error and demonstrated incompetence.  The Court concluded that the Committee was best placed to make this conclusion as it had heard the evidence of witnesses and the appellant in live format. They further concluded that not only was the decision soundly based but that it was in fact the only one it could properly have reached.

The matter is as yet unreported.

The line between conduct which is simply incompetent and conduct which is so unjustified and incorrect as to be classified as dishonest, is one best drawn by a Panel who has heard expert evidence on the matter and from the Registrant themselves.

Harriet Roberts, Legal Assistant

Share insightLinkedIn Twitter Facebook Email to a friend Print

Email this page to a friend

We welcome views and opinions about the issues raised in this blog. Should you require specific advice in relation to personal circumstances, please use the form on the contact page.

Leave a comment

You may also be interested in:

Skip to content Home About Us Insights Services Contact Accessibility