Report reveals secrecy and fear in maternity unit in a Devon hospital

16 March 2020

We heard from the BBC news today that a report that they had finally gained access to, revealed a lack of trust and low staff morale contributing to a series of problems in maternity care at North Devon Health Care NHS Trust between 2013 and 2018.  This resulted in 11 serious incidents.  The BBC report is a dispiriting read.  The report identified a lack of trust and respect between staff; senior midwifery anxiety that the quality of care was poor; and inaction at the Trust.

There were two elements in the BBC report that struck me as particularly significant.  The first and by far the most important was a parent describing that she had blamed herself and had been “carrying guilt around” for a decade.  This resonates strongly.  We frequently meet with parents of children with profound disabilities as a result of poor obstetric who are filled with questions and self-doubt and have often been battling with social services to get appropriate provision for their child.  They come to us with a heavy heart and needing answers to questions about why they are in the situation they are faced with.

It is deeply disappointing that, it seems in this Trust, some of the parents were not even aware of the outcome of the internal enquiries. That the parents of a child are excluded from the investigation process is unacceptable for two main reasons.  Firstly they have a right to understand what has happened to their child.  Secondly, and equally importantly, their personal narrative may well add important information that permits learning and prevention of future occurrences.

Which brings me to the second element that struck me when I read this particular report which states “In attempts to prevent the release of the full 2017 report, the Trust argued anonymity was required to ensure staff participation in future reviews”.  I strongly refute this argument.  There are very few doctors who would willingly collude with a cover up (and although my language is strong, that is what this appears to be).  If handled appropriately, well supported early enquiries into adverse incidents can help ensure learning and de-stigmatise inevitable adverse incidents. Caring doctors who, almost without exception are doing their best, can return to giving front line treatment without the significant dent to morale that was reported in Devon.

Further information

If you would like to discuss a possible clinical negligence claim please contact one of our Medical Negligence & Personal Injury lawyers on 020 7814 1200, or email us at


Share insightLinkedIn Twitter Facebook Email to a friend Print

Email this page to a friend

We welcome views and opinions about the issues raised in this blog. Should you require specific advice in relation to personal circumstances, please use the form on the contact page.

Leave a comment

You may also be interested in:

Skip to content Home About Us Insights Services Contact Accessibility