Kingsley Napley considers statutory instruments and Brexit

10 September 2018

‘Playing by their own rules?’

Brexit blog series

Many who voted for Brexit did so to ‘Take Back Control’ from the EU, but who will legislative control pass to after Exit Day and what are the possible consequences for our constitution and for all of us? In the coming months, our Public Law team will publish a series of short comment pieces that explore the functions of secondary legislation in the UK, how lawmakers are held to account and the implications of Brexit in this area. See our Public Law Blog and Brexit Blog for more.

In the UK, we tend to assume that legislation achieves “validation and legitimacy through consent by the legislature” (Paul Craig). Unlike an Act passed by the UK Parliament, however, secondary legislation (also known as delegated or subordinate legislation and statutory instruments) refers to legally binding rules that are not made by the elected legislature at all, but by a minister, official or administrative body. The power to make these rules will be conferred by an Act of Parliament, but its exercise will occur at one remove from the House of Commons or the Lords, somewhere in the byzantine machinery of the ‘administrative state’.

Looked at this way, secondary legislation may appear undemocratic. The reality is, however, that the modern state cannot do without it. Parliament has only so much time and society has grown too complex for MPs and peers to satisfy its demand for rules. Many areas of life are highly technical, so it makes sense for Parliament to fix the structure then let the specialists fill in the fine print. Some areas of life are dynamic so rules need to change more quickly than Parliamentary procedure allows. Much modern legislation is no-longer about governing the conduct of private persons. It is “usefully viewed as a set of internal government instructions” telling public bodies the policy they are expected to implement (Edward Rubin). For these and other reasons secondary legislation is now the norm in advanced societies. 

The rise of secondary legislation may be extremely practical and arguably inevitable, but the problem of “validation and legitimacy” is stubborn. We tend to be uncomfortable about faceless bureaucracies going unsupervised, so administrative bodies consult on proposed rules and Parliament increasingly oversees and scrutinises them to maintain legislative quality. After secondary legislation is made it may, importantly, be supervised by the courts. A claimant can apply for judicial review challenging its legal validity and, if it is unlawful, it can be quashed.

Secondary legislation has never been bigger news. As Imogen Sadler has recently written, on top of upwards of 3,000 statutory instruments being made annually in the ordinary course, 800 more are expected to be made to resolve gaps to the statute book caused by the UK’s withdrawal from the EU, at a rate of approximately 35 to 45 a week. Given the uncertain outcome of the Brexit negotiations and the sheer breadth and complexity of subject matter to be legislated for, this task is placing an enormous strain on an already overburdened Whitehall. Effective legislative drafting requires the selection and application of the most appropriate principles to resolve inevitable clashes between competing aims (Helen Xanthaki). This is a blend of art and science but many of those entrusted with the task may be trying it for the first time. The risks of delays, mistakes, impracticality, unworkability and even deliberate executive overreach cannot be overstated.

Secondary legislation is therefore likely to be a big issue in Brexit Britain. With that in mind, our Public Law team will publish a series of short comment pieces on secondary legislation and Brexit in the coming months. Aimed at the general public, these will begin by covering the basics of secondary legislation from why we have it to the powers of the court to review and set it aside. We will then turn to Brexit itself, including examining the basis on which Brexit secondary legislation will be made and examples of the problems posed for selected sectors.

We hope you will join us for this series, entitled ‘Playing by their own rules?’

Subscribe here (please note you must have an RSS reader) or visit our website to see the latest commentary.

An edited version of this blog appeared in the The Law Society Gazette on 17 September 2018. To view the blog, please see page 15  here.

Further information

Lawyers from Kingsley Napley are regularly blogging about a range of legal issues, including Public Law matters and the impact of Brexit. See our Public Law Blog and Brexit Blog  for the latest commentary.

Should you have any questions about the issues covered in this blog, please contact Adam Chapman or a member of our Public Law team.

Brexit Bulletin Board

Brexit Bulletin Board

The EU Settlement Scheme - a guide for EU citizens living in the UK

Click here to play video

Brexit - What EU citizens living in the UK need to know

Read More

Brexit - what British citizens living in the EU need to know

READ MORE

Kingsley Napley's immigration team sponsors Financial and Professional Services Post-Brexit Immigration Briefing

READ MORE

No-deal Brexit: transitional arrangements for EEA nationals arriving after 29 March 2019

READ MORE

EU Settlement Scheme - what you need to know

In this podcast, Gillian Brownlee and Felicity Woof discuss the new EU Settlement Scheme which is due to go live on 30 March 2019.

Listen to the podcast

Post-Brexit data sharing with EU regulators is key for FCA policing market abuse

Read News Item

No deal Brexit: what this would mean for extradition?

Rebecca Niblock blogs

What Brexit means for EU employees living in the UK and their families

View on YouTube

'Playing by their own rules?' - Brexit blog series

Our Public Law team blogs about secondary legislation and Brexit.

View the blog series

Mutual trust remains until we leave: notification of intention to leave the EU not an exceptional circumstance

Read the blog

Holiday home/Retirement planning: will Brexit wreck it?

A question you may ponder as you relax on that sunlounger in the weeks ahead is whether you need to review your arrangements for any EU based property in light of Brexit.

Read the blog

#Brexit: Further clarification on the rights of EU citizens living in the UK: https://bit.ly/2LY0QtA

View Tweet

Brexit and the European Arrest Warrant (EAW): at least now we know what we don’t know

Read the blog

Brexit & Horse Racing

The UK is home to a myriad of sports employing foreign nationals and receiving investments from overseas companies. Learn how Brexit will impact horse racing and all who are part of it.

Read Blog Post

Brexit: "It was not this that I promised to do"

Read the blog

Blackberries, Baking and Brexit

Read Blog Post

Could Brexit send Geraint Thomas into a spin?

Hanging over this year’s Tour de France, at least for this British cycling fan, was the realisation that this is probably the last Tour pre-Brexit, and so there is an additional level of uncertainty about what the 2019 post-Brexit edition will look like.

Read the blog

Brexit and practising rights for lawyers

Two Solicitor friends of mine recently asked me to sign their applications to register with the Law Society of Ireland. I asked them if they were thinking of moving.

Read Blog Post

A change of course? Pondering the future of golf in Brexit Britain

As avid golfers focus their attention on the US Masters in Augusta Georgia next month, many at the 19th Hole will be pondering the impact of Brexit on their beloved game.

Read the blog

UK-EU security cooperation post #Brexit - ringing the alarm bell! | Part II of a two-part guest blog by EU Criminal Law expert Dr Debbie Sayers | #CriminalLaw http://ow.ly/bO0b30jwHfa

View Tweet

Brexit & Motor Racing

The UK is home to a myriad of sports employing foreign nationals and receiving investments from overseas companies. Learn how Brexit will impact motor racing and all who are part of it.

Read Blog Post

Post-Brexit language testing for EEA qualified healthcare professionals

On March 7 2018, the House of Commons Library published a Briefing Paper outlining the language testing requirements imposed upon healthcare professionals who qualified outside of the UK.

Read Blog Post

Kim provides the facts! #stayorgo

View Tweet

Beyond #Brexit: new anti-money laundering regime agreed

No sooner are we one year into the new regime under the Money Laundering Regulations 2017 than a further EU instrument has been adopted.

Read Blog Post

No-deal Brexit and the impact on patient safety

READ MORE

Divorced, beheaded, scrutinised? SIs and Henry VIII powers under review

Read the blog

Share insightLinkedIn Twitter Facebook Email to a friend Print

Email this page to a friend

We welcome views and opinions about the issues raised in this blog. Should you require specific advice in relation to personal circumstances, please use the form on the contact page.

Leave a comment

Recent Public Law Insights

Close Load more

Let us take it from here.

+44 (0)20 7814 1200

enquiries@kingsleynapley.co.uk

Skip to content Home About Us Insights Services Contact Accessibility