20 November 2026

Are the UK’s Talent visas actually attracting talent?

The Migration Advisory Committee (MAC) has just published its long-awaited review of the UK’s talent immigration routes.

The UK wants to attract the world’s best and brightest and our immigration system has specific ‘talent routes’ designed to do exactly that. But are they actually working?

The MAC set out to answer that question, focusing on two routes in particular: the Global Talent visa and the Innovator Founder visa. After months of research, data analysis, stakeholder roundtables, and a Call for Evidence that attracted over 400 responses, the verdict is in.

The Global Talent route

The MAC’s report states that overall; the Global Talent route is performing as it should.

Who’s using it? Primarily academics and researchers, with significant numbers also in tech and the creative industries. Between 2022/23 and 2025/26, around 55,200 Global Talent visas were issued, with numbers growing steadily year on year.

What’s the fiscal picture? The MAC estimates that the average Global Talent visa holder granted in 2022/23 will make a positive net fiscal contribution of around £403,000 over their lifetime. As a cohort, they are expected to contribute around £2.2 billion.

Are they staying? Yes, overwhelmingly. Among those who entered the route at least three years ago, 95% still held valid UK immigration status three years later, and 28% had already obtained settlement (indefinite leave to remain (ILR)).

Are they happy? Largely, yes. A Home Office survey found that 90% of Global Talent visa holders were ‘very’ or ‘fairly’ satisfied with the overall application process.

What needs changing?

Despite the broadly positive picture, the MAC has identified several areas for improvement.

The application process can be inconsistent. Some applicants and legal representatives reported that the same evidence was assessed differently by different assessors, leading to contradictory outcomes. Endorsing bodies acknowledge this is a challenge when assessing something as inherently subjective as ‘talent.’ This is certainly a challenge we have seen applicants encounter in practice and we would welcome greater consistency in the decision making process.

Reference letters are a weak point. Currently, applicants gather their own reference letters and submit them to the endorsing body which could create opportunities for fabrication or pressure on referees to be overly generous. The MAC recommends that reference letters should be submitted directly and confidentially to the relevant endorsing body instead. If that happens, applicants will need to be very clear with their referees exactly what the requirements are for the letters. However, mistakes are likely to be inevitable. In our experience referees’ support is genuine and referees are typically in positions which mean they are not subject to undue pressure from applicants. Due to the status of many referees, they are often very busy and the logistics of direct contact may prove challenging in practice.

Some visa holders have very low earnings. Between 14% and 28% of main applicants had earnings below £22,300 in their second year. The MAC recommends introducing a modest earnings threshold at ILR, set at least at the full-time National Living Wage, to ensure visa holders can support themselves long-term. From April 2027, the National Living Wage will be over £24,000 for full-time workers. Many Global Talent visa holders may not meet this criteria, including those who do not have straightforward income structures (such as people working in tech) or people working in the arts. In our experience a lack of consistent UK earnings is not reflective of an inability to support themselves but rather reflective of the nature of the work these applicants undertake. It also may reflect different pay structures, eg. Equity in early stage start ups, and we would hope that any implementation of these recommendations notes that consistent income does necessarily not reflect the value of the talent.

Earlier this month, the government released its response to the earned settlement consultation. Mandatory earned settlement rules will require applicants to have earned at least £12,571 when they apply for ILR. The MAC estimates that around 8 – 21% of Global Talent main applicants granted visas in 2022/23 had earnings below £12,571 in their second year. The recommendation for the National Living Wage requirement goes further and would set a higher earnings threshold. The earned settlement response indicated that some Global Talent visa holders may qualify for ILR after 3 years and that this is “Subject to review pending MAC report”. See our FAQS on the earned settlement changes for more information (especially question 8).

Consider new fast-track criteria for arts and tech applicants. Fast-track Global Talent visa holders can qualify for ILR after 3 years. The MAC invites the government to consider an expansion of the fast-track route for the endorsing bodies that currently use the assessment route only (Tech Nation and Arts Council England). This would be on the basis that being able to secure a full-time position with prestigious arts organisations or other employers is in itself a sufficient indication of talent. The Home Office would need to decide which organisations will qualify – they would need to be highly reputable with an excellent record of sponsor compliance in the Skilled Worker category.

Guidance is fragmented and confusing. Many applicants struggle to understand what evidence is required, with guidance scattered across multiple websites. The MAC recommends a major review of all guidance, published in one accessible place and updated annually. This would be a very welcome change.

The Innovator Founder visa: a route in crisis

The Innovator Founder visa, which was created to attract entrepreneurial talent to set up innovative, scalable businesses in the UK, is in the MAC’s assessment, not working. This is also reflected in the very low number of applications to the route. The MAC says:

  • The average Innovator Founder business has roughly the turnover of a small independent coffee shop by the time visa holders apply for ILR after three years.
  • The average employment across these businesses is just one to two people (often including the visa holder themselves) suggesting the route is generating very little job creation.
  • Innovator Founder businesses generate substantially lower turnover than comparable UK-owned businesses of the same age.
  • Personal incomes are also low. The median income in year two was just £15,800, and individuals on Innovator Founder visas earn around 62% less than those on the Skilled Worker route.

There are a small number of businesses which perform very well, and Innovator Founder organisations are significantly more likely to have patent applications than comparable UK businesses. But the MAC is clear: the strong performance of a handful of businesses does not make up for the poor outcomes of the majority.

The MAC’s verdict on the Innovator Founder route? Abolish it

The MAC’s headline recommendation is blunt: the government should abolish the Innovator Founder route in its current form.

 

The route is failing to meet its core objectives. Businesses are not innovative, viable and scalable in any meaningful sense for the vast majority of visa holders.

 

If the government chooses to keep the route open rather than abolish it, the MAC sets out a series of urgent reforms:

  • Make it far more selective. Tighten eligibility, strengthen the endorsement process, and place greater weight on founders’ track records.
  • Extend the time to ILR from three to five years, to allow enough time to properly assess whether a business is genuinely succeeding.
  • Introduce a personal income requirement at ILR, set at least at the full-time National Living Wage.
  • Tackle conflicts of interest, endorsing bodies should only be able to sell paid support services to visa holders endorsed by other endorsing bodies, not their own.
  • Improve data collection urgently. The MAC was hampered throughout this review by significant data gaps and recommends a full data overhaul with a re-review in one year.

While we share concerns about the viability of the existing innovator founder route, the UK desperately needs functioning routes for entrepreneurial talent to relocate and build businesses in the UK. If it is to be abolished, a sensible replacement must be found and existing innovators will need transitional arrangements which allow them to continue a journey they started in good faith.

What about the Investor visa?

Many stakeholders called for the reintroduction of some form of investor visa, after the previous Tier 1 (Investor) route was closed in 2022. The MAC’s recommendation is a firm no but this is very much a decision grounded in the issues the previous investor visa faced.

The committee recommends against reinstating a standalone investor visa, and also against adding investors to either the Global Talent or Innovator Founder routes. There are a number of interesting suggestions for a new investor route which would address the problems identified with our last investor visa. These deserve specialist consideration so that the UK can continue to attract people who genuinely wish to invest in the UK. See some of our recent commentary on this issue here.

What next?

The MAC is clear that what matters is whether these routes are genuinely achieving their objectives. On that test, the Global Talent visa passes with room for improvement; the Innovator Founder visa does not. It’s now in the government’s court as to whether they heed the MAC’s recommendations alongside the upcoming earned settlement rules.

While these recommendations are being reviewed, we continue to support clients with all aspects of the Global Talent route. We have extensive experience advising on and preparing Global Talent applications, including addressing many of the challenges and considerations highlighted in the MAC report. If you would like assistance with a Global Talent application, guidance on the issues discussed above, or support with any other immigration matter, please do not hesitate to contact our immigration team.

About the author

Abigail Watt is an associate who specialises in a broad range of both private client and corporate immigration matters with a specific focus on the following visa categories: Minister of Religion and Religious Workers; Global Talent – Arts Council; Creative Workers; and Skilled Worker and Sponsor licence applications

Contact_us

Let us take it from here

Whatever your legal needs, we’re here to help.

Contact us