19 November 2026

Physician and Anaesthesia Associates: regulation, controversy and the future of practice

Where it all started

The General Medical Council (GMC) began regulation of Physician Associates (PAs) and Anaesthesia Associates (AAs) on 13 December 2024. This move was not without controversy, as it raised concerns about whether placing these professions alongside doctors adequately distinguished between fundamentally different training pathways and scopes of practice.

Against a backdrop of heated debate was one of the most significant developments in the form of an independent review led by Professor Gillian Leng, published in July 2025. The principal aim of the review was to determine whether the roles of PA and AA were safe and effective as members of a Multi-Disciplinary Team (MDT). Professor Leng concluded that considering all the factors there was no convincing reason to abolish the roles of PA or AA but there were a number of significant issues that needed to be addressed to effectively embed the roles into the NHS workforce. The review made 18 recommendations, all of which the Government has accepted. Some of the key recommendations included:

  • The role of PAs should be renamed as ‘Physician Assistant’ to reflect the role as a supportive, complementary member of the medical team.
  • There should be the opportunity for PAs and AAs to have ongoing training and development in the context of a formal certification and credentialling programme.
  • PAs should not see undifferentiated patients, except within clearly defined national protocols, as it was noted that safety concerns in relation to PAs were almost always about making a diagnosis and deciding on initial treatment.
  • Newly qualified PAs should gain at least 2 years’ experience in secondary care prior to taking a role in primary care or a mental health trust, as secondary care provides an environment with much greater supervision, such that safety issues can be identified promptly.
  • The roles should form part of a clear team structure and standardised measures should be employed to distinguish them from doctors.
  • Permanent faculties should be established to provide professional leadership.
  • Anaesthesia Associates should be renamed as ‘Physician Assistants in Anaesthesia (PAA)’ and there should be a national audit of safety outcomes in anaesthesia practice to provide assurance on safety.

NHS England subsequently issued instructions to employers in July 2025, translating some of the reviews recommendations into immediate expectations.

The litigation

The courts have also become an important part of the debate. In January 2025, permission was granted for a judicial review against the GMC, alleging a failure by them to regulate associates in a manner which complies with their over-arching patient safety objectives (R (Anaesthetists United Limited; Marion Chesterton; Brendan Chesterton) v General Medical Council [2025] EWHC 2270 Admin). On 5 September 2025, Lambert J handed down judgment, dismissing the claim on all grounds.

There was also a separate challenge by the British Medical Association (BMA) concerning the GMC’s use of the collective term ‘medical professionals’ but this was also unsuccessful (R (British Medical Association) v General Medical Council [2026] EWCA Civ 143).

The claims look far from over, as on 1 October 2026, United Medical Associate Professionals (UMAPs) secured permission for judicial review in respect of grounds against NHS England, the Secretary of State for Health and Social Care and Professor Leng. This claim is in respect of the decision to rename the professions. The case will now proceed to a substantive hearing.

As of 13 December 2026, GMC registration becomes a legal requirement to practise using the protected PA and AA titles. Clearly a lot has changed for PAs and AAs over the past two years and the journey towards statutory regulation has been complex and contentious. What began as an initiative to expand the NHS workforce and improve access to healthcare has evolved into a debate about professional identity and patient safety. For PAs and AAs there will be much greater professional accountability as a result of their GMC registration and the direction of travel is towards more clearly defined responsibilities, stronger supervision arrangements and greater consistency.

Concluding remarks

Statutory regulation marks an important milestone for PAs and AAs, but questions about professional identity, scope of practice and accountability remain. As legal challenges continue, the priority must be clearly defined roles, effective supervision and consistent practice. Ultimately, these reforms must deliver clarity for professionals and patients, with patient safety at their core.

With over 60 years’ experience working with major UK regulators, Kingsley Napley provides practical advice to professionals and organisations facing regulatory scrutiny, compliance issues and governance risks.

If you would like to discuss any of the issues raised in this article, please contact Louise Murphy-King or a member of our Regulatory team.

About the author

Louise Murphy-King leads complex fitness to practise investigations on behalf of regulatory bodies in the education and healthcare sectors. As part of her role she advises clients on the prospects of success, strategy and the appropriate means for disposal of cases. She is also responsible for leading on process improvement for one of the department’s largest clients as well as delivering internal and external training on process improvement.

Contact_us

Let us take it from here

Whatever your legal needs, we’re here to help.

Contact us