This quarterly civil fraud update provides a summary of reported decisions handed down in the courts of England and Wales in the period of July – September 2026.
Abuse of Process
In Salinas Pliego v Astor Asset Management 3 Ltd (mentioned in my civil fraud case update Q4 2025) the Court of Appeal considered the lower Court’s approach to abusive behaviour. The principles which govern the Court’s response to abuse are: to protect the Court’s process, rather than punishment; to deter abusive behaviour; and that any response must be proportionate. There was no basis to apply a default rule that obtaining or seeking to obtain confidential and privileged information would lead to a strike out of a party’s entire claim. The Court of Appeal concluded that strike out of a summary judgment application was correct, but also that the punishment should go further: the abusive conduct had been committed at the time that freezing injunctions were obtained. Had the Court known about the conduct at the time, the injunctions would not have been continued. As such it was appropriate and proportionate that they be discharged.
APP Fraud
The Court of Appeal in Moorwand Ltd v Hamblin upheld an appeal against a High Court judge’s decision to allow an appeal from the Court below following the dismissal of a claim relating to an APP fraud. The first instance judge’s decision that the electronic money institution was not on enquiry was available on the evidence. Interestingly, as I discussed in my civil fraud case update Q2 2020, the claim was brought by way of a derivative action on behalf of the electronic money institution’s corporate customer.
Contempt
The Court granted permission to the defendant in Foot Anstey LLP v Stimpson to admit fresh evidence in contempt proceedings. The Court considered the three-stage test for relief from sanctions but concluded that the most important consideration was that the defendant’s full case should be before the Court where his liberty was at stake.
A passport order (mentioned in my civil fraud case update Q1 2026) was continued in Frischmann v Vaxeal Holdings where a second application for committal for contempt had been made in circumstances in which it was alleged that the defendant had failed to provide disclosure. The Court ordered that the passport would be returned once specific documents had been disclosed.
The Court of Appeal in Windhorst v ADS Securities LLC dismissed an appeal against an 18 month suspended prison sentence for contempt. The appellant had breached numerous orders including a consent order containing an undertaking to attend a hearing, which he then failed to attend.
Deception
The Court in Capitana Seas 2008 v Libya struck out a trust’s application for permission to appeal the setting aside of county court consent orders obtained by a fraudster which sought to relitigate questions about title to a valuable property. The consent orders had been obtained by deception and the proceedings had been an abuse of process. The application for permission to appeal was totally without merit.
Directors Duties
The Supreme Court considered the scope of directors’ duties, and in particular the fiduciary duty of loyalty, in Saxon Woods Investments Ltd v Costa. The case involved the actions of one director who covertly took steps which he genuinely believed were in the best interests of the company, but which were contrary to an earlier agreement by the shareholders. The Supreme Court confirmed that the duty under s. 172 Companies Act 2006 required directors not only to think, but also to act in good faith.
In Gable Insurance AG v Dewsall (previously mentioned in my civil fraud case update Q3 2025) the Court of Appeal considered whether a director had acted dishonestly in making “excessive payments” from a company he was a director of to a company he wholly owned. Where the director believed he had board authorisation, had disclosed the payments to the company’s auditor, had guaranteed repayment and genuinely believed that the payments would be repaid, that behaviour could not be characterised as dishonest by the standards of ordinary people.
Freezing Injunctions
The Court in Ciright Inc v Centili Group Ltd continued a proprietary injunction despite failures of full and frank disclosure at the without notice hearing. Discharging the injunction would lead to an unjust outcome. The Court also refused to order fortification of the cross-undertaking in damages as there was insufficient evidence of risk of loss.
In Khawaja v (1) Stefanova (2) Biotechnologies UK Ltd (3) Dermamed Solutions Ltd the Court refused an application to discharge a freezing injunction. Delays in progressing the proceedings were not attributable to the claimant/respondent who had asked for a CMC to be listed. Earlier delays were caused by the applicant making applications which were found to be wholly without merit.
The Court of Appeal dismissed an appeal against a High Court decision (which I discussed in my civil fraud case update Q1 2026) that the appellants in Gilbert v Broadoak Private Finance Ltd had established no gateway for service out of the jurisdiction. The appellants had obtained a Chabra order against a respondent in Spain and tried to rely on the Enactment Gateway under CPR PD 6B para 3.1(20)(a) for service out. The Court of Appeal found that s.37 Senior Courts Act 1981 was a general provision which contained no claim-conferring language. It set out the jurisdiction available to the Court, rather than creating a statutory claim. As such a claim for a freezing order could not be characterised as a claim “under” s.37 and the Enactment Gateway for service out could not be used.
Injunction
In Noda Holding Ltd v Zips the Court refused to make an interim injunction under s.25 Civil Jurisdiction and Judgments Act 1982. The claim had not been made out to the relevant standard and damages would be an adequate remedy. There was an interim injunction in place in Cyprus and the English Court was reluctant to make an order which might be overlapping and raised a risk of inconsistency.
The Court refused to make an injunction in Lambert v Lambert. There was a serious issue to be tried, but the injunction was unworkable: it would compel a father and son to live together after a catastrophic break down in their relationship. The interim relief went beyond the final relief sought. The son was entitled to return of his personal possessions, but was not entitled to a proprietary injunction where he was not able to offer an unlimited cross undertaking in damages. Likewise the Court refused to make a freezing injunction as the evidence was inadequate.
Judgment Debt
The Court considered an application by the claimant in Zabelin v SPI Spirits (UK) Ltd to be paid money due under a judgment from money paid into Court by the judgment debtor. The judgment debtor resisted the application on the grounds that there was a reasonable suspicion that the UBO of the claimant’s company was subject to Russian sanctions. The Court granted the application: there was no evidence of ownership which would engage the sanctions regime and in any event the claimant was in the UK and payment would be made to the claimant, not to his company.
Jurisdiction
The Court concluded in Ebert v Ferrari SpA that s.33(2) Senior Courts Act 1981 did not permit proceedings for pre-action disclosure to be brought outside the jurisdiction in relation to documents located abroad. Instead, the Hague Convention on the Taking of Evidence Abroad in Civil or Commercial Matters 1970 applied.
The Court of Appeal in Sucden Financial Ltd v TMT Metals AG dismissed an appeal seeking to reverse a decision to dismiss an application to set aside an order granting service out of the jurisdiction. The High Court had granted permission to serve out under the tort damage gateway where a claim had been made in tort for damage sustained within the jurisdiction. The appellant challenged whether damage had been sustained within the jurisdiction. There was no definitive test for where damaged occurred: the Court had to look at the tort and ask whether damage had resulted from substantial and efficacious acts committed within the jurisdiction.
Set Aside
The Court of Appeal in Lindsay’s Estate v Outlook Finance Ltd considered whether a judgment set aside on the basis of the first defendant’s fraud and dishonesty should also be set aside as against the second defendant. Where the second defendant had adopted the position and evidence of the first defendant, and where it had been established that the first defendant’s evidence was fraudulent, it was appropriate to set aside judgment as against the second defendant, even where the second defendant had no knowledge of the fraud.
Please contact Mary Young from our Civil Fraud and Investigations team to discuss the implications of these developments for your business.
About the author
Mary Young is a Partner in the Dispute Resolution team. Her practice covers a wide range of areas but Mary’s particular interests and expertise lie in civil fraud and asset tracing as well as claims against professionals in negligence, breach of fiduciary duty and breach of trust.
