Wills, Trusts and Inheritance Disputes FAQs

Validity challenges

On what grounds can I challenge a Will?

You can contest a Will on the basis that it is invalid by relying on one or more of the following grounds:

• The Will has not been correctly executed;
• The testator lacked the necessary mental capacity;
• The testator lacked knowledge or approval of the contents of their Will;
• The testator was subject to undue influence;
• The Will is forged/fraudulent.

You may alternatively consider that the Will is valid but feel that you have not been sufficiently provided for (if at all) and therefore think about making a claim under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975.

End.

Can a will be challenged before death or after probate?

A Will does not come into effect until a testator has passed away. If you have concerns about the validity of a will during the testator’s lifetime, no claim to challenge its validity can be pursued until the testator has passed away however you can attempt to address your concerns about its validity with the testator directly.

Claims challenging the validity of a will should ideally be brought before the Grant of Probate is issued in order to ensure the assets in the estate are preserved and no distributions are made until the dispute is resolved. A caveat can be lodged to prevent a Grant of Probate being issued. If a Grant of Probate has already been obtained, you can still challenge a Will however you should seek to obtain advice as soon as possible.

End.

How do I challenge a Will?

Claims rarely begin with the issue of proceedings and most commonly initially involve correspondence between the parties and/or their lawyers. Setting out a good claim carefully and exploring another parties’ strengths and weaknesses is a necessary starting point, rather than getting drawn into emotive correspondence and making inflammatory allegations. Early disclosure can resolve disputes, as can obtaining expert reports.

In all cases, Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR), particularly mediation, should be considered. If the dispute cannot be resolved by agreement, a claim form will need to be issued in court supported by a properly pleaded case, following which the opponent will serve a defence. The exact procedure will depend on the relief or remedy being sought. The court will then lay down a directions timetable to trial, which will include requiring the parties to disclose documents and exchange witness evidence.

The vast majority of cases are settled before trial, but if that is not possible it is likely that it will take approximately 12 to 18 months to reach a trial from when the court proceedings were issued. If you are a Personal Representative, your role in the proceedings will often be neutral, subject to some specific exceptions.

Who is entitled to a copy of a Will and how can a person obtain a copy of the Will before probate?

Only the executors appointed in a Will are entitled to view the will before the Grant of Probate has been granted. If an executor refuses to allow you to see the Will or provide you with a copy before the Grant of Probate is granted, they cannot be required to do so.

However, in practice, it is unusual for a Will not to be provided if requested.  There is case law (Larke v Nugus (1979))which confirms that if a solicitor has taken instructions and prepared a Will, the solicitor is a material witness and should therefore provide the information in advance and make available any documents in their possession that are relevant to any proceedings. This also avoids the cost of unnecessary applications to court. If it becomes necessary to issue and application for disclosure of the Will and associated documents, the solicitor may be liable for the costs of that application.

Generally, after the Grant of Probate has been issued, the Will becomes a public document and anyone can then apply to the Probate Registry for a copy.

End.

When should I bring a claim?

Timing can be of critical importance in probate disputes, and a relaxed approach might have disastrous consequences. For example, any claim under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependents) Act 1975 must be made within six months of the issue of the Grant of Probate.

Likewise, urgent action may be required to protect assets in the meantime, whilst claims are under consideration. We have the experience to know which deadlines are crucial and what steps need to be taken to protect our clients' interests and the capacity to react accordingly.

End.

Will I need to go to court?

It is unlikely, since you will only need to go to court if the case goes to trial. If the case does go to trial you will almost certainly attend court and give verbal evidence along with the other witnesses. If there is to be a settlement before trial, it is possible that you will need to come ‘face to face’ with your opponent at a meeting or mediation.

End.

What is a "no contest" clause?

A no contest clause (also known as a forfeiture clause) is a clause in a Will which states that a beneficiary will forfeit their inheritance if they challenge the Will.

A beneficiary should always check for the existence of a no contest clause before challenging a Will because, if their challenge is unsuccessful, they will lose their legacy.

Naturally, if a challenge to the validity of the Will is successful and the whole Will is found to be invalid, the no contest clause won’t apply. 

End.

How will I know if the correct formalities have been followed when executing a Will?

There are a number of requirements to ensure that correct formalities have been followed, including:

• The person making the Will must have testamentary capacity i.e. be over 18 years of age and of sound mind;
• The person making the Will must do so voluntarily, without undue influence and must know what the will says;
• The Will must be in writing; and
• The Will must be signed by the person making the Will in the presence of two witnesses and then be signed by the two witnesses, in the presence of the person making the will, after s/he has signed.

End.

How can I tell if the deceased lacked capacity when the Will was drafted?

An individual will be considered to have sufficient mental capacity to make a Will if he understands the following:

• The nature of the act of making a Will and its effect, i.e. that he is setting out to whom he wishes his property to pass on his death;
• The extent of his property; and
• The individuals for whom he is morally bound to provide and the consequences of not providing for such individuals.

If a Will appears rational then there is a presumption that the testator had mental capacity and the Will will be admitted to probate unless anyone can produce sufficient evidence to the contrary.

If you have doubts about the capacity of a testator then the best place to start is probably the file of the solicitor who prepared the Will.

When making a Will for an elderly or ill testator, or anyone with dubious testamentary capacity, it is best practice for the solicitor to obtain a written medical opinion and, if possible, to arrange for a doctor to witness the signing of the Will. If either of these steps have been taken, it will be difficult to challenge the testator’s mental capacity.

In the absence of a medical opinion or doctor’s signature as a witness, there may be a file note made by the solicitor, commenting on the testator’s capacity and referring to their behaviour and state of mind at the time of execution of the Will. This may also provide good evidence that the testator had the requisite testamentary capacity.

It should be noted that the usual deterioration of memory with old age does not necessarily mean that the testator lacks capacity and, even if there are general doubts about the testator’s capacity, a Will may still be valid if it can be shown that it was made during a lucid interval.

End.

How would a want of knowledge or approval claim arise?

These claims arise when the circumstances surrounding the making of a Will appear to be suspicious. A testator must have knowledge and approval of the contents of a Will in order for it to be valid. In these cases, the onus of proof is put on the party relying on the disputed Will to show that it reflects the testator’s testamentary influence. Claims of this type are particularly common in respect of homemade wills.

End.

How would an undue influence claim arise?

If you suspect that the testator has done something that they might not have done had it not been for the influence of another (usually the main beneficiary under the Will) a claim under this ground may arise. Effectively, the testator’s own judgement has been abandoned having succumbed to the manipulative behaviour of another. In order to succeed, the claimant must be able to show that the testator was coerced into making the Will.

End.

What form might a claim in relation to a fraudulent or forged Will take?

The Will might have been prepared by a beneficiary who forged the signature of the testator either before or after their death. In these types of claim, a handwriting expert would normally be instructed.

A Will could be fraudulent if the testator has left someone out that would otherwise have benefited on the basis of misrepresentations made by another person.  Alternatively, whoever drafted the Will on behalf of the deceased could have left a large portion of the estate to himself without the deceased knowing.

End.

Am I entitled to any inheritance if the Deceased did not leave a Will?

When somebody dies and there is no will in place or no valid Will in place, they are said to die ‘intestate’ and their estate will pass according to a fixed statutory order of entitlement.

If your partner passes away and you were married and you have children, you will receive all of his or her personal effects and the sum of £250,000 (subject to it being available). The remainder of his or her estate will be divided into two equal shares. You will receive the income from one of the shares for the rest of your life, with the capital being preserved for your children after your death. The other share will pass to your children in equal shares.

If you are married without children and your spouse is survived by either or both of their parents or whole blood siblings, you will receive all of his or her personal effects and the sum of £450,000. As above, the remainder of his or her estate will be divided into two equal shares but this time you will receive one share absolutely. The other share will pass to your spouse’s parents in equal shares if they are still alive, failing which to your spouse’s siblings in equal shares.

If you are married without children and your spouse is not survived by either or both of his/her parents or whole blood siblings, you will receive the entire estate outright.

If you are not married to your partner, you will not be entitled to anything at all.

If someone other than a partner passes away, the rules of intestacy provide for what you may be entitled to and we will be able to advise on this.

You are able to bring a claim under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975 if you believe that insufficient provision or no reasonable provision has been made for you under the Intestacy Rules, please see the questions of the 1975 Act below.

End.

What if I disagree with the way an executor is performing their duties?

There are various reasons which a beneficiary may wish to challenge an executor of a Will. If they feel that an executor is not performing their duties, there are some steps which can be taken to either get the executor to renounce their position or not take up the role in the first place.

• Renunciation

This is where the executor steps down if they decide that they do not want to act, or decide that they cannot act following the death of the testator. This step cannot be taken if an executor has taken active steps in dealing with an estate.  Once a grant of probate has been obtained, he cannot simply step down and other steps will need to be considered.

• Where the executor is taking undue delays in obtaining probate, an application can be made for a “citation” to either force the executor to take steps, or let someone else deal with the estate. Where this sort of application is made, a caveat should first be lodged to prevent the grant or probate being obtained.

• If it is felt that an executor is unsuitable for the role, then an application can be made to the court to “pass over” the named executor, and appoint someone independent. If this happens, the court has discretion in selecting the appropriate person to take the grant.

• If an executor has already started to administer the estate, a beneficiary can request a copy of the estate account to show what steps an executor is taking. If the executors delay unreasonably or refuse to provide accounts you can make a formal application to court for these to be provided.

• If there are serious issues with an executor which cannot be remedied, it may be necessary to make an application for the removal or replacement of the executor. The court will not agree to remove an executor simply because there is a disagreement with a beneficiary. The court will consider whether the estate can be properly administered with that executor in the role.

• It is also possible to bring a claim against an executor personally if it is found that through their administration, there has been a loss to the estate – for example, selling estate assets at an undervalue.

End.

I disagree with a joint executor – can I do anything?

It is usual that, through correspondence, joint executors can come to an agreement as to what would be in the best interests of all of the beneficiaries. However, joint executors do need to act in agreement in order for probate to be progressed.

If an agreement cannot be reached, or an executor of the estate is not performing its duties, and the grant of probate has already been issued, then it is possible for one executor to make an application to court to remove the other; or alternatively if a dispute with a joint executor cannot be resolved, and the grant of probate has already been issued, then it is possible for one executor to make an application to court to remove the other. 

End.

The Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975: claims for reasonable financial provision

What is the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975? How do I know if I am eligible to make a claim under this?

The Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants Act) 1975 (the Act) enables certain categories of persons to make a claim against an estate provided they can show that they were financially dependent on the deceased and that the deceased did not make adequate provision for them in their Will. Any claim under the Act must be made within six months of the issue of the Grant of Probate.

The following categories of persons are eligible to make a claim under the Act:

• A current spouse or civil partner of the deceased;
• A former spouse or civil partner of the deceased who has not remarried and who has not received a final financial settlement following the breakdown of the marriage or civil partnership;
• Any person who, during the whole two year period immediately before the date of death, was living in the same household as the deceased in the manner of a spouse or civil partner;
• Any child of the deceased including illegitimate, legitimated and adopted children of any age;
• Any person treated by the deceased as a child of the marriage or civil partnership;
• Any person not included above who was maintained wholly or partly by the deceased immediately before his death otherwise than for valuable consideration. The requirement of ‘no consideration’ excludes paid domestic staff from having a claim under the Act.

End.

What factors does a court take into account in a claim under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975?

Under Section 3 of the Act, the court will take into account the following factors when deciding whether a reasonable financial provision has been granted for a claimant:

a) the financial resources and needs of the applicant;
b) the financial resources and needs of any other applicant;
c) the financial resources and needs of the beneficiaries;
d) any obligations and responsibilities of the deceased towards any applicant and any beneficiary;
e) the size and nature of the estate of the deceased;
f) any physical or mental disability of any applicant or beneficiary;
g) any other matter, including conduct, which the court may consider relevant.

In relation to an application by a surviving spouse, the court is also required to consider:

a) The age of the applicant and duration of the marriage;
b) The contribution made by the applicant to the welfare of the family of the deceased, including any contribution made by looking after the home or caring for the family.

End.

My spouse or partner has not provided for me in their Will - is there anything I can do?

As a spouse or partner of the deceased (providing you were living in the same household as the deceased in the two year period immediately before his death) you would be eligible to make a claim under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975.

Spouses and civil partners are entitled to such provision as it would be reasonable in all the circumstances for them to receive (whether or not that provision is required for their maintenance). Amongst other factors, the  court will consider the age of the applicant and the length of the marriage, the applicant’s contribution to the welfare of the deceased’s family and the provision which the applicant might reasonably have expected to have received if, instead of the marriage being terminated by death, the marriage had instead been terminated by divorce.

End.

My mother or father has not provided for me in their Will - is there anything I can do?

As a child of the deceased you would be eligible to make a claim under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975.
The claim is limited to such provision as would be reasonable in all the circumstances for the applicant to receive for his or her maintenance.

The fact that you are estranged from your mother or father would not affect your eligibility to make a claim against their Will under the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975. Your estrangement will however almost certainly be taken into account by the Court in assessing the strength of your claim.

Traditionally, the courts have been reluctant to make provision for able bodied, adult children under this Act but recent case law has suggested a greater sympathy towards such claims.

End.